Pharrryngula
Jolly Roger

Wednesday, June 22, 2005

A damsel that doesn't need any knights

Ischnura hastata

Who needs males?

The Azores archipelago lies 1,500 km from th' coast o' Europe, pass the grog! Inspired by a report that only females o' th' damselfly Ischnura hastata had e'er been found there, Cordero Rivera and his team visited 15 localities on six o' th' islands. Although more than 330 adult specimens o' I. hastata were examined, none o' them were bein' male. To test whether th' species were bein' parthenogenetic, a sample o' larvae were bein' reared t' adulthood in th' laboratory—more than 1,900 females were produced o'er nine generations, but no males.

The explanation is fairly simple: species that are adapted t' rapidly exploit new and/or widely dispersed habitats, like islands, experience a different mix o' selection pressures than us staid plodders. If ye are a far-flung scout who has just discovered a perfect environment fer yer kind, it does no good if all ye can do is hover about waitin' fer another scout who happens t' also be o' th' other sex t' stumble on it, as well—'tis better if ye can just buckle down t' it and reproduce solo.

And 'tis not just in th' Azores!

There have also been intriguin' accounts o' other damselfly species on remote archipelagos. In particular, on th' islands o' Fiji, it seems that females o' th' damselfly Nesobasis rufostigma actively defend territories o'er aquatic habitats, whereas th' males, which are infrequently encountered, reside some distance from th' stream. This phenomenon has been dubbed 'sex-role reversal' and, if confirmed, would be th' first example in an odonate. If males are in short supply, then this unusual matin' system might be explained by female competition fer access t' males. Furthermore, males o' two rarer Fijian damselflies (N, I'll warrant ye. flavostigma and N. caerulescens) have ne'er been found, raisin' th' possibility that parthenogenesis occurs in these species.


Sherratt TN, Beatty CD (2005) Island o' th' clones. Nature 435:1039-1040.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2459/Vc78D2tf/

Comments:
#29408: — 06/22  at  01:00 PM
What a coincidence! National Geographic has a slightly different article on damsel flies here.



#29412: jre — 06/22  at  01:22 PM
If I recall correctly, Willy Ley mentioned in his superb Exotic Zoology that a fish native t' th' Sargasso Sea appeared t' be exclusively female -- though th' selection pressures favorin' parthenogenesis in that case are not so obvious (at least not t' me).



#29417: — 06/22  at  02:07 PM
This raises a question that I have often wondered about: What is th' competitive advantage o' gender. I think I savvy why sexual reproduction is favored (more rapid diversification), pass the grog! But why specialize into fertalizers and fertalized? Ahoy! Why isn't simultaneous hermaphroditism a dominant strategy?



#29418: Raven — 06/22  at  02:08 PM
Ah, fish sex!

If I recall correctly, Willy Ley mentioned in his superb Exotic Zoology that a fish native t' th' Sargasso Sea appeared t' be exclusively female


jre, ye're right, but among some species, it gets even weirder than merely straight parthenogenesis--fer example, th' male angler fish burrows into th' skin o' th' female, gettin' his nutrition from that comely wench. Meanwhile, his anatomical structures (except gonads) atrophy, until he is basically just a parasitic sperm donor.

The Amazon molly (poecila formosa) is a strictly-female species, who coexists with related bisexual species, and mates with their males. But th' sperm does not fuse with th' egg; it just stimulates parthenogenesis, so they split th' difference--they mate sexually, yet reproduce parthenogenetically.

Tetrapods are just so vanilla.



#29420: Mrs Tilton — 06/22  at  02:15 PM
Any role here fer Wolbachia, I wonder?



#29431: — 06/22  at  05:43 PM
This is th' conversation I always wish would happen when ethicists, professional or otherwise, are worryin' out loud about human clonin'. If ye want t' know what th' ramifications fer humans might be if we were t' switch from always reproducin' sexually t' sometimes makin' due with just one set o' DNA, why not ask another species that sometimes reproduces sexually and sometimes doesn't, we'll keel-haul ye! What are th' consequences fer th' offsprin', fer th' population, etc.

But no, we get creepy dead-child replacement scenarios and growin' people in pods so we can hack out their organs when ours go bad. Sigh.



's avatar #29432: PZ Myers — 06/22  at  05:52 PM
Mrs T: The article mentions that they scrutinized th' animals fer known parasites -- di'nae find any that might cause this.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#29434: Jim — 06/22  at  06:34 PM
Fabulous illustration o' evolutionary pressure operatin'in situ.



#29442: coturnix — 06/22  at  08:09 PM
Tetrapods are OK. There are parthogenetic lizards.



#29458: Raven — 06/22  at  09:58 PM
True. Ahoy! So, PZ, which species is kinkiest?



#29461: Daniel Newby — 06/22  at  10:14 PM
How do anglerfish merge their circulatory systems without provokin' a massive immune response, by Blackbeard's sword? Conversely, what defenses against parasites did they have t' give up?



#29464: Raven — 06/22  at  10:38 PM
Oooh, good questions, Daniel. Our vert repro biology course were bein' more o' an overview than an intensive concentration, so they got presented t' us in a survey o' possibilities, more than th' in-depth implications, so I really dern't know th' details.

I did take a vert endocrinology course, where we talked a lot about th' hypothalamo-pituitary axis in fishes and in tetrapods, and th' take-home point our prof wanted t' get across were bein' that these structures are much more highly innervated and vascularized in tetrapods than in fish--because, surrounded by fluid, hormones can be delivered very easy outside o' th' circulatory system, while on land, that possibility were bein' lost, so a lot o' angiogenesis had t' take place t' make up fer th' delivery o' th' hormones. So as far as that goes, analogous circulatory and endocrinological functions can be very different in fish than in land animals, because o' th' marine environment, and maybe that plays a role in th' circulatory and immune considerations ye brin' up. But now I am speakin' strictly ex rectum, so I'll leave off th' speculation here.



#29520: — 06/23  at  10:05 AM
I am not a biologist (I'm from th' dark side, that is, chemistry)..., me beauty. these rare species where only females have been identified- is there any chance th' males look radically different and have been identified as a different rare species? I seem t' remember sexin' flies as bein' very difficult, ye scurvey dog? Have any species been described that are all male?



's avatar #29528: PZ Myers — 06/23  at  10:32 AM
Sexin' flies is easy. Shiver me timbers, with a chest full of booty! There is some concern that species with extreme sexual dimorphism might go unrecognized, but that's not a problem here: th' lab experiments where 9 generations o' females were produced by only females rules that out.

Since this kind o' thin' defines females as animals with ovaries that produce eggs, no, ye can't have a species that is all male.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#29533: — 06/23  at  11:16 AM
...he is basically just a parasitic sperm donor.

That pretty much goes fer male Homo sapiens, too, Raven, although we are good fer openin' jars...



#29535: — 06/23  at  11:26 AM
Nine generations in th' lab should've been a clue! Ahoy! So much fer me powers o' data assimilation and/or readin' comprehension.



#29542: Raven — 06/23  at  12:07 PM
You know, zilch, when I wrote that, I were bein' concerned that I might be thought t' be male-bashin'. But then I remembered that I'd be all right in writin' it down, because th' exception proves th' rule.



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: Microsoft lowers th' bar a little more

Previous entry: Are we ready fer th' "larger argument"?

<< Back to main

Info

portrait
email PZ Myers
About Pharrryngula...
Search
 Normal Mode 

Members

Login | Register | Members

Syndicate

RSS 2.0
Atom

Recent articles

The LAST post on old Pharyngula

Tangled Bank #105

Tangled Bank #104

Tangled Bank #103

Tangled Bank #102

Tangled Bank #101

A taste of pharyngula

Tentacle sex

Basics: Gastrulation, invertebrate style

The burden of bearing a massive penis

Evolution of alcohol synthesis

Ancient rules for Bilaterian development

No genes were lost in the making of this whale

Squid attack!

Squid Hox genes

The Panda's Thumb

Looking for Dr. 900

Tangled Bank #113

Carnival of Evolution!

Steve Steve in London

Giardia lamblia, polyadenylation, and irreducible complexity

Genome Biology: "It is alive" by Gregory A Petsko

Tangled Bank #112

The gift that keeps on giving: Steve Fuller

The AAAS responds to "Expelled"

New Features

Random Dozen

xml My Left Wing - Front Page: My Left Wing

xml Curly Tales of War Pigs: (null)

xml Bajillion: (null)

xml homunculus: (null)

xml decorabilia: (null)

xml Library Stuff: The library weblog dedicated to resources for keeping current and professional development

xml 90% True: Now with 12% more truth!

xml Framed: Discourse & Democracy

xml The Dispersal of Darwin: (null)

xml Adventures in Ethics and Science:

xml Pseudo-Random Quanta: (null)

xml VirJournal: A Vivisection of Virge

Complete Blogroll
Pharyngula.opml