Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Saturday, June 04, 2005

Book plague

Oy, I've been passed a book meme. It's about books, and it's short, so I can't pass it up.

Last Book bought:

On the Origin of Phyla by James W. Valentine. It hasn't arrived yet, so I can't say much about it. There are no good bookstores near me (well, there is a decent used bookstore in Alexandria, about 45 minutes away), so most of my book purchases are by mail, and there's a lag between desire and satisfaction.

Last Book read:

Savage Run by C. J. Box. There's a whole series of these stories about a crime-solving game warden in a small town in Wyoming, and they're not bad.

I picked it up in our town library, with which I have a love-hate relationship. It's a nice library, with a supportive staff, and they do occasionally pick up interesting books—but they also reflect some truly scary community tastes. I swear, half their stock consists of Louis L'Amour and Harlequin Romances. They have a shelf of the new acquisitions near the front, and what I'm seeing dribbling into the library are bucketloads of Christian/Apocalyptic fiction. Everything Jenkins and LaHaye write gets picked up as soon as it is published, but there are these other long, long series of religious novels that I've never heard of before that I see on the shelf: The A.D. Chronicles, The Cross and the Crown, something that looks like apocalypse horror with the tagline, "Pray for the light", and more…it's just bizarre.

Five Books that Meant A Lot:

What does that mean? And only five? I guess I'll just pick a random subset that have made an impression on me, with an attempt at keeping the list diverse. I could pack this with an easy dozen biology books, you know.

The Sea-Hawk by Rafael Sabatini. I read all of Sabatini's books as a kid, and just about anything to do with seafaring. There was a time in my youth when, if a square-rigged ship had sailed into Puget Sound on a provisioning stop prior to heading to the South Seas, I would have been gone. Just my luck, nothing stopped by.

Childhood's End by Arthur C. Clarke. Once, when I was laid up with appendicitis, my dad made a trip to the library to stock up on reading material for me. He actually went into the adult section and came back with a number of things, but this was the one I remember. I read it, and thought to myself, "So that is science-fiction!" and was hooked for life.

Gilgamesh : A Verse Narrative by Herbert Mason. I found this in my late teens, when I'd experienced a whole series of losses, and it meant a great deal to me: I wasn't alone, the death of loved ones is something humanity has been suffering with for its entire existence.

Sociobiology by E.O. Wilson. This book came out when I was a freshman in college and taking piles of chemistry and math, but no biology…so I got it and read it to see if biology really was what I wanted to do with my life. Forget the controversies, forget the philosophical issues—I was dazzled by the breadth and depth of Wilson's writing on the subject. Oh, yeah, I was going to be a biologist.

Developmental Plasticity and Evolution by Mary Jane West-Eberhard. Like Sociobiology, this is a magnificent survey. It's not easy reading, but wow, does it ever hit the real controversies in biology hard, raising interesting questions on every page.

I'm supposed to pass this along to other people, but just naming them isn't evil enough. Instead, I'm just going to say that anyone who comments on this article is required to sate the devouring meme themselves.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2378/4X1huDLg/

Comments:
#27222: Alon Levy — 06/04  at  11:37 AM
Yesterday I bought Biology as Ideology and Collapse at the same time. Expect a scathing attack on Lewontin as soon as I decide to actually read his book.



#27223: Matt McIrvin — 06/04  at  11:54 AM
Ha ha! I already did!



's avatar #27225: PZ Myers — 06/04  at  11:57 AM
Oh, goodie. I love Biology as Ideology -- we can have a good fight.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#27227: Alon Levy — 06/04  at  12:01 PM
Oh, alright. Just be careful because I may end up liking it yet, but from what I know about it so far, it's highly unlikely.



#27228: Jamie — 06/04  at  12:03 PM
I'm a couple chapters into Carrol's Endless Forms Most Beautiful, thanks to your mention, PZ. The information in this book is so . . . I don't know what to do with myself - it's, well, beautiful. Much thanks to you for bringing it to our attention!

Also in the middle of Democracy Matters by Cornel West. While I do consider theism-bashing the second funnest indoor activity, Dr. West is a theologian I can't help but respect. With the theocons pushing IDC, war, and greed, it's easy to get cynical, but West puts things in a brighter light for us progressives.



#27229: Joseph ODonnell — 06/04  at  12:19 PM
About the only thing I've got left to read is a book called The Civil Wars, by Kenyon and Ohlmeyer. It's mostly about how Religious differences put most of England into a civil war for various reasons during 1638-1660. It's not that easy to get into however without some background knowledge of the English monarchs and parliament though from around Queen Elizabeth.



#27236: Editor - 201k — 06/04  at  02:31 PM
If you like The Civil Wars try The Cousins' Wars by Kevin Phillips. Traces a religious line from the English Civil War through the American Revolution and the American Civil War.



#27243: — 06/04  at  03:34 PM
Last book finished: Adrienne Mayor's 'The First Fossil Hunters.' Who knew the old Greeks painted dinosaurs on their kraters?

I was led to that book while searching Barnes & Noble online for those ID books that Professor Myers et al. listed a while back. (I have now finished several of them and am roaring with laughter at Plantinga's contribution in Pennock's 'Intelligent Design Creationism & Its Critics.') As usual with me, I got sidetracked onto several different paths, one of which led me to the latest book I have opened, Wallace Arthur's 'Biased Embryos and Evolution.'

I'd very much like Professor Myers' opinion on this one. (I bought it because I liked Arthur's 'Theories of Life' so much.)

5 That Meant a Lot:

Grahame, 'Wind in the Willows' (last child's book I read in a childlike way)

Herodotus, 'The Histories' (first adult book I read in an adult way)

Treece, 'The Green Man' (sexiest book my wife and I read together)

Morris, 'The Age of Arthur' (taught me how to evaluate evidence)

Sassoon, 'Memoirs of a Fox-hunting Man' (best coming of age novel ever)



#27259: — 06/04  at  07:40 PM
Sabatini--most excellent, especially Captain Blood. I never outgrew those adventure stories. Jack London and Joseph Conrad wrote some terrific yarns about seafaring but "Two Years Before The Mast' by Richard Henry Dana Jr. (a true story) is a personal favorite. The historical fictions by George MacDonald Fraser especially the ' Flashman' series are very entertaining also.



#27270: coturnix — 06/04  at  08:39 PM
Ah, I just got hit with the same meme. I did the other book meme (the Fahrenheit one) recently and not much has changed since then. I'll have to think hard. I have six "must get soon" titles in mind (and on my blog) for the next purchase, but no money yet.

BTW, isn't the first question: "How many books do you have?"



#27296: — 06/04  at  10:54 PM
Just finished Bryan Sykes' Adam's Curse; been wanting to read it since I read Seven Daughters of Eve. Interesting, but I think he goes rather overboard on blaming the Y-chromosome for various social horrors.

"How many books do you have?"

No idea. Lost count a long time ago. We've got them everywhere and usually have several going at once.



#27315: — 06/05  at  12:40 AM
Last bought: Philip K. Dick, Cantata-140 and Tom Holt, The Portable Door (both at a bookstore at London Heathrow).

Last read: Ursula LeGuin, Changing Planes

Five books? Why is it that we humans have to do things by fives, instead of threes or fours? How about Jules Verne, "Twenty Thousand Leagues under the Sea", Goethe's "Faust" (in which the devil is much cooler than the pointy-headed intellectual), "The Snail on the Slope" by the brothers Strugatsky (or their "Definitely Maybe"), "Labyrinths," Jorge Borges.

The most influential book I've ever read is probably Intel's "8-Bit Embedded Controllers."



's avatar #27361: Nullifidian — 06/05  at  10:48 AM
Last book bought:
Stuart Sim's Fundamentalist World: A New Dark Age of Dogma
Truly remarkable, if disheartening, book about how various 'fundamentalisms' are guiding many aspects of the political, economic, and religious world.

Last book read:
Thomas Cahill's Sailing the Wine-Dark Sea: Why the Greeks Matter
Fascinating book from a humanities aspect, but gave short shrift to the influence of the Greeks on the course of political history (including military history) as well as in mathematics and the sciences. In short, you'll only agree that the Greeks matter, based on the arguments in this book, if you agree that the humanities are important.

Five Most Influential Books:
E. O. Wilson's The Future of Life
If I were independently wealthy, this is a book I'd put in all hotel rooms in place of the Gideon Bibles. It's an incisive and eye-opening book on the current state of the world and how we must act now if we're to preserve biodiversity on earth.

Howard Zinn's A People's History of the United States
The power of the powerless--nothing more needs to be said.

J. L. Mackie's Ethics: Inventing Right and Wrong
A classic defense of moral skepticism, and a necessary corrective to the strange fundamentalistic bent of many discussions on morality. It's as if it doesn't matter how much harm or benefit one's views do, rather that one has inflexible moral views and damn the consequences.

Rudolf Raff's The Shape of Life
This book got me hooked on biology.

Taner Edis' The Ghost in the Universe: God in Light of Modern Science
This book made me realize that one could legitimately make a strong inductive case for the non-existence of god. It, along with Julian Baggini's Atheism: A Very Short Introduction, which makes the point about defeasible and indefeasible positions, turned me into a positive atheist.

"We are obliged, therefore, to spread the news, painful and bitter though it may be for some to hear, that all living things on earth are kindred.” Edward Abbey, Desert Solitaire



#27374: — 06/05  at  12:22 PM
I'm surprised; I had the impression you didn't like science fiction. Don't know where I got that idea from....

The latest book I just got back from picking up: The Rise of the Indian Rope Trick, by Peter Lamont. Had an interesting conversation with the salesgirl when I ordered it; she'd never heard the expression "Indian Rope Trick" before, and wasn't really enlightened when I described the thing. "Well, that was the nineteenth century," she said, "they believed all sorts of odd things then." I was tempted to give her a rundown of the sort of things people believe these days....

If graphic novels count, then the last book I read was Brief Lives, by Neil Gaiman. Otherwise, Flashman's Lady, by Ian McDonald Fraser.

Five books that meant a lot. That's a toughie. Try this semi-random assortment:

The Mismeasure of Man, by Stephen Jay Gould. It's nice to have a book that summarises the bullshit and then demolishes it.

The New Science of Strong Materials, by J.E. Gordon. Helped me relate the somewhat academic physics I'd been taught in school to stuff in the real world. Forms a useful diptych with Structures, by the same author.

Essential Kanji, by P.G. O'Neill. After a period in the doldrums, flicking through this book in odd idle minutes has started to reawaken my interest in Japanese.

Use of Weapons, by Iain M. Banks. Intelligent and literate space opera. Not recommended if you like linear narratives, though.

Red/Green/Blue Mars, by Kim Stanley Robinson. A classic trilogy. Some find the pace a bit slow, though.



's avatar #27379: PZ Myers — 06/05  at  01:44 PM
I did find Robinson to meander a bit too much for my taste, but Fraser is terrific, and Banks is my all-time fave SF writer.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#27381: — 06/05  at  01:46 PM
I haven't read Cahill's book on the Greeks but his book on the Irish was full of errors. E.R. Dodds' 'The Greeks and the Irrational' is absolutely essential to any study of the Greeks.

I second Nels on Gordon's books. He brings great clarity to an abstruse subject. Because two of my children are theater people, whenever we're in Manhattan we go to The Drama Bookstore, and I was moderately surprised to find 'Structures' there my last trip.

(Professor Myers can count himself lucky. I am 2,500 miles from the nearest competently staffed bookstore.)



#27424: SocraticGadfly — 06/05  at  11:25 PM
Cool... I'll play.

Last book read: Currently, Unintelligent Design by Mark Perakh. Definitely very good so far.

Last book read. Well, between interlibrary loans, my library getting more and more galley copy books and the trickle of nonfiction review copies that come into my newspaper office, I rarely buy anymore.
But, out of a set of four purchased dirt-cheap at Half Price Books was Eight Men Out by Eliot Asinof. I learned a lot about the background of the Black Sox.

Five highly influential books?
1. Without Guilt and Justice by Walter Kaufmann. A takeoff of sorts on Beyond Good and Evil. He blows John Rawls' moral philosophy out of the water.

2. Cadillac Desert by Marc Reisner. How -- and why -- the American West is probably going to -- and should -- dry up and blow away within 50 years.

3. Q, by John Kloppenberg, for the Jesus Seminar. An academic overview of the putative source behind common sayings material in Matthew and Luke, it started me on the path from my conservative Lutheran divinity degree studies to my current atheism.

4. What If/What If 2, edited by Robert Cowley. Simply the best, most mentally stimulating books of counterfactual history.

5. The Mind's I, by Daniel Dennett and Douglas Hofstadter. Although I disagree with a fair amount of Dennett's theorizing on both consciousness (including the egotistic title of "Consciousness Explained") and think Gould was right vs. him on the amount of randomness in macrobiological development, it still stimuluated me enough to buy or check out every book he's written.



#27425: SocraticGadfly — 06/05  at  11:27 PM
Oops, I typed "last book read" twice. The second one should be last book bought.



#27505: — 06/06  at  08:52 PM
I seem to be making a habit of commenting on posts after everyone else has gone home; but I wanted to say that Childhood's End is crap.
The premise is that real science is a diversion, everything anybody ever believed about ESP, telekinesis blah blah blah was right, and that humankind's destiny is to shed our physical bodies and become purely spiritual beings.

Yuck. How does this qualify as science fiction?

(I can understand enjoying as a child, I admit. In fact I adored Rendezvous with Rama and am now afraid to reread it lest I be disappointed... let alone the sequels.)

Alright, so I had better do the honorable thing and follow the rules.

Most recent book read:

Complications: A Surgeon's Notes on an Imperfect Science, Atul Gawande

Surely PZ would enjoy this one. It has a great chapter on necrotising fasciitis, although the use of maggots in treating this is apparently too new-fangled to get a mention. (Before that: The Cat Who Walks Through Walls by Robert Heinlein, not much good, sadly.)

Book most recently purchased: this is a tie.

Tycho and Kepler, Kitty Ferguson
The Baby Book, William and Martha Sears
Nourishing Traditions, by Sally Fallon with Mary G. Enig

(and yes, there is some unscientific content lurking in the pages of that last one, in case anyone wants to call me on it.)

Five influential books:

The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, Douglas Adams, my first introduction to a series which in various media has wasted a prodigious amount of my time.

Stark, Ben Elton. Hilarious, environmentally minded and very disturbing.

The Usborne Guide to Computer Programming or some similar title, which forever ruined me as a computer programmer by teaching me BASIC.

Progress and Poverty, Henry George. Who reads shall find in Henry George's philosophy a rare beauty and power of inspiration, and a splendid faith in the essential nobility of human nature. -- Helen Keller

Pride and Prejudice, Jane Austen. 'nuff said.

That's five already. I'll also mention Rich Dad Poor Dad by Robert Kiyosaki, which really gave me a kick in the pants, although I'll make no claims in defense of its merit.

Bye now.



's avatar #27507: PZ Myers — 06/06  at  09:02 PM
Oh, I agree. I read Clarke in my early teens, enjoyed it very much...but I can't stand his stuff anymore.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



's avatar #27510: Chris Clarke — 06/06  at  09:38 PM
But what about...

Oh.

Never mind.

"I do not think we should antagonize the religious when it is not warranted, though I think we should be willing to do so whenever it is.”
-- Glen Davidson



#27512: — 06/06  at  09:47 PM
I just bought a copy of Darwin's On the origin of species today, found a hardback version being sold fairly cheap.
I just couldn't resist.
smile

Five influential books?

I think I'd have to put Carl Sagan's Demon Haunted World up there as pretty close to the top.

Then there'd be the Edmonds Cookery Book (a New Zealand tradition). I don't know that there's an American equivalent to it, but think of a book that's been in print since 1955, (my copies the 44th edition) and is pretty much a cooking bible for first year students.

The Night's Dawn trilogy by Peter F. Hamilton was a good sci fi series that I enjoyed reading, verging on some 3000 pages in total I think.

Mary Shelley's Frankenstein struck me as a really good read as well, especially considering she was 19 when it was written.

Model selection and multimodel inference by Burham and Anderson. Though I guess I tend to do demographic analyses with my work, still this book offers a useful framework for selecting the best model during an analysis.

And no-body has mentioned Tolkein?



#27932: — 06/09  at  11:37 PM
Last book purchased - something like Spanish pronouns made easy (I will be fluent someday)

5 Books with meaning....

1) Goodbye Darkness A Memoir of the Pacific War - William Manchester
2) Night - Elie Wiesel
3) Stalingrad - Antony Beever
4) Hitler's Willing Executioners - Daniel Jonah Goldhagen
5) Doctors of Death - Philippe Aziz

It still amazes me what evil man can do to his brother.



#28019: — 06/10  at  07:20 PM
For anyone who is interested, Project Gutenberg has most, if not all, of Sabitini's books available, as well as much of the literature that is in the public domain. One of the internet's great resources.



#28020: — 06/10  at  07:28 PM
I suspect public libraries do cater to popular tastes to some extent, and westerns and romances are by far the most popular, for whatever reason. But I did get Sean B. Carroll's "Endless Forms Most Beautiful" from my local county library almost immediately after it came out. You might be surprised what you can find if you look closely enough.



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: Tweaking the site a little bit

Previous entry: Let's bash the media some more

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college