Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Tuesday, October 04, 2005

Goosing the CHE

The Chronicle of Higher Ed often seems to be a reactionary sort of place, with a fondness for curmudgeonly luddites and fake controversies (see Tribble, Ivan), so it's good to see a positive article on this strange enterprised called "blogging": The Blogosphere as a Carnival of Ideas:

Why are so many academics beginning to blog? Academic blogs offer the kind of intellectual excitement and engagement that attracted many scholars to the academic life in the first place, but which often get lost in the hustle to secure positions, grants, and disciplinary recognition. Properly considered, the blogosphere represents the closest equivalent to the Republic of Letters that we have today. Academic blogs, like their 18th-century equivalent, are rife with feuds, displays of spleen, crotchets, fads, and nonsenses. As in the blogosphere more generally, there is a lot of dross. However, academic blogs also provide a carnival of ideas, a lively and exciting interchange of argument and debate that makes many scholarly conversations seem drab and desiccated in comparison. Over the next 10 years, blogs and bloglike forms of exchange are likely to transform how we think of ourselves as scholars. While blogging won't replace academic publishing, it builds a space for serious conversation around and between the more considered articles and monographs that we write.

It helps that it's written by a credible source, Henry Farrell of Crooked Timber, which is probably the best of the academic blogs—he has cause to see the promise of the medium.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/3059/QeayOX5k/

Comments:
#42653: coturnix — 10/04  at  08:59 AM
That is an excellent article.



's avatar #42655: Raven — 10/04  at  09:12 AM
I must have missed this earlier--what's the trouble with Tribble's?



#42660: coturnix — 10/04  at  09:28 AM
Ivan Tribble wrote an article about someobody not getting an academic job BECAUSE of having a blog. A good starting point for the reaction is this post (and links within) by Rebecca Goetz or you can survey broader here.



's avatar #42668: Raven — 10/04  at  10:08 AM
Thanks, for the references, coturnix. Nice touch, CHE letting "Tribble" post his nasty pseudonyms anonymously like that. Clearly, I'd much rather interview and work with someone like Farrell, anyday.



#42690: — 10/04  at  11:38 AM
I guess I must be somewht of an anomally because I don't practice a religion that my parents followed or that of my social network. In fact my 30-yearpractice of Nichiren Buddhism originally stemmed from the fact that I had become disenchanted with the dominant religion of this country.

Buddhism didn't require me to reject good science, and it put ultimate responsibility for success and failure sqarely where it belonged-in my own hands. I never needed to appeal to a Cosmic Micromanager to have meaning in my life. The teachings of Nichiren taught me how to do that for myself. My life is the source of meaning. It is my spiritual functionality.

GE



's avatar #42703: Raven — 10/04  at  01:57 PM
Hey, coturnix--where'd your quail go?



#42727: coturnix — 10/04  at  06:28 PM
Ah, the gravatars are gone, I guess!



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: Avian flu adventure

Previous entry: Why are people against evolution?

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college