Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Thursday, June 30, 2005

Here's one museum we can all skip

America has gone mad. The Smithsonian was snookered and made a quick and reasonable recovery from their flirtation with scientific frauds, but will the Cleveland health education museum overcome this taint?

The Cleveland health education museum will open its doors to faith healer Dr. Issam Nemeh on July 10, creating an unusual venue for a purported miracle healing service.

HealthSpace Cleveland waived the customary $5,000 rental fee for Nemeh, said Patricia Horvath, the executive director.

Sad to say, all signs say no. The museum board seems to be well stocked with credulous idiots.

"We decided not to charge them because a number of board members are supporters of Dr. Nemeh's work," Horvath said.

"We see spiritual health in the holistic view of overall health," she said.

Dr. Ted Castele, chairman emeritus of the health museum, is among those whose stories of being helped by Nemeh were featured on WEWS Channel 5. Nemeh's popularity surged on a series of televised reports claiming miracle cures under his hands.

Castele, a former medical reporter for the station, said his frozen shoulder regained mobility after Nemeh prayed for him. "Whether physical therapy caught on or it was faith healing, that's up to each individual to decide for themselves," Castele said in an interview.

Grace Drake, a museum trustee and former state senator, said she had no problem with Nemeh using the museum.

"He has had some good results, and people have testified to that," she said. "I'm sure most people are quite ill who do this, and God bless them."

How did these people get to be in charge of a science and medicine museum?

As for this Nemeh phony, he's a faith healer—he and his wife "cure" people by laying on of hands and prayer—and acupuncturist. I guess they must whip out the needles when God is too busy to do his magic.

The Plain Dealer reported earlier this month that Nemeh's method of acupuncture requires only a five-day training course and uses a device not approved by the Food and Drug Administration for clinical safety or effectiveness. The paper also reported that Nemeh had sued after being kicked out of a medical residency program at Fairview Hospital. The paper also reported that even though Nemeh claimed he worked as an anesthesiologist at Richmond General Hospital for several years, officials at the hospital said Nemeh worked there for only four months.

Quack, quack, quack.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2527/frCdE88U/

Comments:
#30406: andy — 06/30  at  09:21 AM
"Whether physical therapy caught on or it was faith healing, that's up to each individual to decide for themselves," Castele said in an interview.

Hmmm, medical science or mumbo-jumbo... I can't possibly imagine which was responsible.

Reminds me of how my mother thinks God saved her when she was in hospital and her death was likely. I suppose all the doctors working hours on end in her room and in the operating theater were just props.



#30407: — 06/30  at  09:24 AM
It's pretty clear that this is not really a science museum. It's a place where space is available for rent. In this case, the people running the place waived the rental fee for a quack as a professional courtesy.



#30408: — 06/30  at  09:28 AM
Hey, this Castele guy with the frozen shoulder? He stiffed me. I just now prayed for him, and retroactively healed him. He should have paid me months ago.

And this Nemeh phony? He couldn't heal a bisected planarian. Sure, he's clairvoyant- otherwise he wouldn't have been able to horn in on me. But who isn't?



#30409: — 06/30  at  09:30 AM
Oh, I think an exhibit on people like this definitely belongs in science museum, but it ought to be in an historical section, clearly marked with a sign "Frauds and Quacks in Health Care." Clearly that's not the case here.



#30410: — 06/30  at  09:35 AM
Terrible, just terrible. I hope to see strongly worded statements from the world renowned medical institutions down the road, Cleveland Clinic, University Hospitals, and Case Medical School.



#30411: Orac — 06/30  at  09:38 AM
Arrrrgghhh! Not in Cleveland. I did my residency at Case Western Reserve University.

Of course, that means I can't help but point out that this "Health Education Museum" is right across the street from CWRU's arch-rival, The Cleveland Clinic. I don't know if there is any affiliation, but at least its closer proximity to the CCF makes me happy. At least Case's medical library, the Allen Memorial Library and its attached health museum, the Dittrick Medical History Center would never go in for that kookiness.

The Dittrick Medical History Center, by the way, has in its collection of 179 letters by Darwin to his contemporaries.

--
Orac “A statement of fact cannot be insolent.”
http://oracknows.blogspot.com



#30412: Cameron — 06/30  at  09:46 AM
Along the same vein, this book is doing quite well on Amazon:

The Biology Of Belief: Unleashing The Power Of Consciousness, Matter And Miracles by Dr. Bruce Lipton

Here's how it is described:

The Biology of Belief is a groundbreaking work in the field of New Biology. Author Dr. Bruce Lipton is a former medical school professor and research scientist. His experiments, and those of other leading-edge scientists, have examined in great detail the processes by which cells receive information. The implications of this research radically change our understanding of life. It shows that genes and DNA do not control our biology; that instead DNA is controlled by signals from outside the cell, including the energetic messages emanating from our positive and negative thoughts. Dr. Lipton92s profoundly hopeful synthesis of the latest and best research in cell biology and quantum physics is being hailed as a major breakthrough showing that our bodies can be changed as we retrain our thinking.

Scary but you might find it fun to desconstruct. His published work as listed on pubmed doesn't seem to back up the book descriptions claims.



#30415: Mike P — 06/30  at  10:19 AM
"Whether physical therapy caught on or it was faith healing, that's up to each individual to decide for themselves," Castele said in an interview.


The postmodern prometheus. Ugh.



#30416: — 06/30  at  10:22 AM
It is amusing that Amazon is selling Lipton's book as part of a two-book set, and since they have space limitations, they relist the title of the book as "The Biology of Belief: The Power of Con..." If only they had added "Artists" at the end!



#30419: — 06/30  at  10:36 AM
It shows that genes and DNA do not control our biology; that instead DNA is controlled by signals from outside the cell, including the energetic messages emanating from our positive and negative thoughts.


That's a....... novel concept



#30420: WatchfulBabbler — 06/30  at  10:48 AM
Orac, you'll be happy to know that the Cleveland Clinic hosts one "Center for Integrative Medicine," which has pimped^H^H^H^H^H^H supported Nemeh in the past. (They also took $300,000 in federal funds to study something called "energy healing" for prostate cancer patients -- though, one hopes, not in lieu of radical prostatectomy.) The Age of Unreason dawns.



#30423: Orac — 06/30  at  11:02 AM
Unfortunately, the institution where I am presently faculty also has such a Center. It also wouldn't surprise me if Case has one too. It's a trend fueled by patient demand. There's also an "energy healing" trial going on here as well....

--
Orac “A statement of fact cannot be insolent.”
http://oracknows.blogspot.com



#30424: — 06/30  at  11:21 AM
"Energy healing?"

Does that mean x-rays? Or perhaps some kind of heat therapy? Yes, of course. That must be it. Or maybe they mean kinetic energy? You know, drop the person with a painful stomach cancer off the top of a building onto his head, and he won't feel the pain from the cancer any more.



#30428: Orac — 06/30  at  11:50 AM
Nope. Sadly, they mean qigong, from traditional Chinese medicine.

--
Orac “A statement of fact cannot be insolent.”
http://oracknows.blogspot.com



#30429: Brad R. — 06/30  at  11:52 AM
Sad to say, all signs say no.

Daaaaaaangerously close to our trademark slogan there, Sr. Myers wink



#30430: — 06/30  at  11:53 AM
Boy, this is conforting. I can see in the future, next time I go into a hospital, I won't see the usual doctor white robe.. I'll see a priest with a bible.

"Camon son, put your hand on the bible and pray with me.."

"BUT MY LEG IS BROKE! IT SURE AS HELL ISN'T MOVING BACK INTO PLACE!"

or scenario 2:

"Camon son, hold your leg up here.. wait..**crack** Thats better"

**in tears** "Thanks a ton!"

"Don't thank me! God did it!"


shudder**

-----
"As with all of ID, the important thing is first to have the concept. Production can then follow as a matter of course.” -Dembski



#30432: — 06/30  at  12:18 PM
The great escape available to faith healers and other like-minded quacks is that a failure to heal can be blamed on the patient: he didn't pray hard enough, or he had sinful thoughts, or he didn't truly repent. In any event, it's all the patient's fault, not the healer's.



#30433: — 06/30  at  12:20 PM
Dr. Nemeh is not in it for the fame and fortune...

http://www.badthinking.com/blog/archives/2005/03/issam_nemeh_cit.html

Dr. Nemeh’s wife said he will not go to Florida because of previous commitments. She said the doctor will pray for Schiavo and her family.

... and, if I recall, Montel says that Sylvia Browne doesn't make any money from healing...

... and there are pink monkeys up my nose, (IIRC, of course)...



#30435: Mark Trodden — 06/30  at  12:31 PM
I just emailed my friends in the CWRU physics department - Lawrence Krauss and Glenn Starkman. They hadn't heard about it but are going to write letters of protest and generally complain loudly. Hope it has some effect.



#30436: Orac — 06/30  at  01:13 PM
Is that the same Lawrence Krauss who wrote the books about the physics of Star Trek?

--
Orac “A statement of fact cannot be insolent.”
http://oracknows.blogspot.com



#30438: — 06/30  at  02:16 PM
I wrote an email to HealthSpace (I'm at Cleveland State) -- I'm a little surprised since the Plain Dealer mentioned in Dr. Myers' post came out a few weeks ago and was definitely not flattering:

http://www.cleveland.com/living/plaindealer/index.ssf?/base/living/111857733970140.xml&coll=2

(this will get you through to article without reg/archive fee)



#30439: — 06/30  at  02:30 PM
Is Qigong useless? I mean, it seems to be very relaxing. Maybe it's just a placebo effect, but, if so, we ought to do research on how to harness the power of the placebo.



#30441: — 06/30  at  03:36 PM
Maybe it's just a placebo effect, but, if so, we ought to do research on how to harness the power of the placebo.
Yes, we should definitely take full advantage of our species ability to lie to ourselves! It's much cheaper than prescription drugs, anyway.

Of course, sometimes it turns out that it wasn't really the placebo effect at all...

A "Breakthrough" study on EEG of meditation:

http://www.sci-con.org/articles/20050601.html

Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

-Jerry Garcia



#30465: Raven — 06/30  at  10:42 PM
Abby:
Maybe it's just a placebo effect, but, if so, we ought to do research on how to harness the power of the placebo.


The thing about placebos is that you can't count on them to be reproducible. So they may work to some degree for some people, but not for others, and you can't really tell in advance which group someone belongs to.

Complicating the difficulty is the distinction between clinical practice and basic research. Often, a clinician will take the point of view that as long as it isn't actively harmful (e.g., cost too much, prevent patient from seeking effective treatment, or dangerous in itself), then if the patient perceives benefit, then why not? But basic scientists (also called bench scientists) 1) don't see patients and 2) do try to find out the basic biological mechanisms of why something works (or doesn't). From that perspective, no knowledge is gained from the placebo effect.

So it is possible that clinicians might be interested in promoting the placebo effect in cases where it is not harmful (especially if there is no effective standard treatment), but not basic scientists. In that case, the clinicians might be interested in a study that showed a correlation between the placebo and the desired treatment effect, but you could not show true causation, because you're not getting at the real treatment mechanism.



#30472: — 07/01  at  02:10 AM
As a Northern Ohioan, I remember the Health Museum as being pretty good in my Seventies childhood, except for a docent who couldn't pronounce "testosterone." There was the Big Ear and the Big Brain and the fetuses at various stages of development and the Big Wound, which taught you about inflammation. I noticed some disconcerting changes when I returned a few years ago. All the exhibits had the names of pharmaceutical-company patrons in big letters behind them and the Hall of Sexually Transmitted Diseases had been eliminated. Much more child-oriented and feel-good stuff, such as the Labyrinth of Defeating Your Anxieties. Populist pressure -analogous to what Orac calls "patient demand"- is undoubtedly a factor. I expect that funding with personal or corporate strings attached to make up for a dearth of state support plays a big role too.



Page 1 of 2 pages  1 2 >

Next entry: The Creationist Patrol!

Previous entry: It's summer! Tests shouldn't be allowed!

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college