Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Wednesday, October 27, 2004

Homo floresiensis, Flores Man

Echoed on the Panda's Thumb

A long-lost cousin has been discovered, Homo floresiensis, or Flores Man. It's especially dramatic for a number of reasons. It's relatively recent, with the youngest specimen only 18,000 years old, but it is most closely related to Homo erectus. This species was also minute, only 3 feet tall, and tiny-brained. Here we have a group of small, specialized human relatives, living contemporaneously with Homo sapiens, on isolated islands in Indonesia. It's like discovering that Munchkins were real. You can read more here:

Flores Man
The LB1 cranium and mandible in lateral and three-quarter views, and cranium in frontal, posterior, superior and inferior views. Scalebar, 1cm.

A real pleasure of working in a historical science like biology is that sometimes you can be completely surprised by some unexpected, odd, and entirely accidental discovery. Flores Man is such a wild surprise.

A new human-like species - a dwarfed relative who lived just 18,000 years ago in the company of pygmy elephants and giant lizards - has been discovered in Indonesia.

Skeletal remains show that the hominins, nicknamed 'hobbits' by some of their discoverers, were only one metre tall, had a brain one-third the size of that of modern humans, and lived on an isolated island long after Homo sapiens had migrated through the South Pacific region.

"My jaw dropped to my knees," says Peter Brown, one of the lead authors and a palaeoanthropologist at the University of New England in Armidale, Australia.

The find has excited researchers with its implications—if unexpected branches of humanity are still being found today, and lived so recently, then who knows what else might be out there? The species' diminutive stature indicates that humans are subject to the same evolutionary forces that made other mammals shrink to dwarf size when in genetic isolation and under ecological pressure, such as on an island with limited resources.

Flores Man adds an interesting twist to our hominid phylogenies. As you can see in this diagram, we now have to add this slender thread from the great Homo erectus dispersal, a relic species that survived long after it's closest relatives.

Flores Man
Homo floresiensis in the context of he evolution and dispersal of the genus Homo. a,The new species as part of the Asian dispersals of the descendants of H. ergaster and H. erectus, with an outline of the descent of other Homo species provided for context. b, The evolutionary history of Homois becoming increasingly complex as new species are discovered. Homo floresiensis (left) is believed to be a long-term,isolated descendant ofJavanese H. erectus, but it could be a recent divergence. 1, H. ergaster/African erectus; 2, georgicus; 3, Javanese and Chinese erectus;4, antecessor; 5, cepranensis; 6, heidelbergensis; 7, helmei; 8, neanderthalensis; 9, sapiens; 10, floresiensis. Solid lines show probable evolutionary relationships; dashed lines, possible alternatives.

Cryptozoologists are going to have a ball. Henry Gee already has an article up, mentioning "that other species of recently extinct humans might be discovered on other isolated islands", and even mentioning the possibility of extant hominids.

The accompanying paper on the archaeology also shows the tools found with these little hominids; these weren't simple apes. They were making some wicked weapons and carving tools.

Flores tools

Despite its ability to make tools, though, Flores Man was small-brained, small even for its diminutive size.

brain/body ratios
The relative brain and body size of H. floresiensis. The dimensions of the skull and skeleton (LB1) described by Brown et al. fall well outside the extremes seen in H.sapiens and the ‘erectines’(a range of hominin species, of which H. erectus is the most familiar). LB1 is closer in size to, but even smaller than, the australopithecines, of which the best known example is Lucy. On various anatomical grounds,however, Brown et al. believe that LB1 represents a dwarfed H.erectus.

Look at that: 1m tall, with a 380 cm3 brain. And shaped stone tools. That is simply amazing.


Flores Man reconstruction

There's also an article on Flores on the National Geographic site, including the nice reconstruction to the left.

National Geographic provided funding for the research, and are going to be airing a documentary on the subject next year.


They also summarize the little guy's life style:

The Flores people used fire in hearths for cooking and hunted stegodon, a primitive dwarf elephant found on the island. Although small, the stegodon still weighed about 1,000 kilograms (2,200 pounds), and would pose a significant challenge to a hunter the size of a three-year-old modern human child. Hunting must have required joint communication and planning, the researchers say.

Almost all of the stegodon fossils associated with the human artifacts are of juveniles, suggesting the tiny humans selectively hunted the smallest stegodons. The Flores humans' diets also included fish, frogs, snakes, tortoises, birds, and rodents.

Morwood MJ, Soejono RP, Roberts RG, Sutikna T, Turney CSM, Westaway KE, Rink WJ, Zhao J-x, vandenBergh GD, Rokus Awe Due, Hobbs DR, Moore MW, Bird MI, Fifield LK (2004) Archaeology and age of a new hominin from Flores in eastern Indonesia. Nature 431-435.

Brown P, Sutikna T, Morwood MJ, Soejono RP, Jatmiko, Saptomo EW, Rokus Awe Due (2004) A new small-bodied hominin from the Late Pleistocene of Flores, Indonesia. Nature 431:1055-1061.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/1454/XulWHTvN/

Comments:
#7704: — 10/27  at  03:12 PM
18,000 years ago is like yesterday. It is breath-taking to think about this species existing so recently. One can almost imagine that a similar species could have existed into historic or near-historic times.



#7706: DarkSyde — 10/27  at  03:38 PM
can you imagine how we'd have treated these guys if they had survived to say, Medieval Times? I wouldn't be surprised if we'd bred them like dogs into various breeds for slaves and pets; assuming we didn't hunt them to extinction for sport.



's avatar #7709: PZ Myers — 10/27  at  03:55 PM
I doubt that we'd be able to breed them: they were relatively intelligent. Like a lot of species, I suspect that they wouldn't cope well with captivity, and trying to raise them would be just another way to drive them into extinction.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#7710: — 10/27  at  03:55 PM
One thing I like about science is that, every now and then, it leaves me flabbergasted.



#7711: — 10/27  at  04:00 PM
A pity Heuvelmans isn't alive to see this - the orang pendek in, well, not in the flesh, but the next best thing. There are reports of a dwarf hominid from the bigger Indonesian islands to the north of Flores, and some of them are quite recent - 20th century. It's a well-documented cryptid. So some of these dwarf hominids may have survived into historical times after all.



#7712: DarkSyde — 10/27  at  04:01 PM
You're ruining my Baxterian fantasy here PZ. It is just fukcing amazing though eh? The creationists on couple of boards are just stumped as to how to spin it.



's avatar #7713: PZ Myers — 10/27  at  04:01 PM
Also gobsmacked, flummoxed, agog, thunderstruck, and discombobulated.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#7714: teep — 10/27  at  04:04 PM
Pretty darn nifty, really. I kinda wonder what the creationists will make of it -- probably just another round of denials, though. There's no convincing some people.



#7715: — 10/27  at  04:07 PM
sometimes you can be completely surprised by some unexpected, odd, and entirely accidental discovery. Flores Man is such a wild surprise.


Aha! You see? Darwinists were taken aback by this discovery! Therefore Evilooshun is false. It's false, I tell you!!! Wibble wibble, gibber, snark, wibble....



#7716: DarkSyde — 10/27  at  04:08 PM
surely that can get some base pair sequences out of something this young?



's avatar #7717: PZ Myers — 10/27  at  04:11 PM
Have you read the article? The bones weren't even fossilized, they were so recent. Unfortunately, they were also found in a warm, damp tropical jungle -- they had the consistency of mashed potatoes. I suspect there's not going to be any DNA at all that's still intact.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#7718: — 10/27  at  04:13 PM
At least we know what happened to Smeagol. So did they find the One Ring too?



#7719: DarkSyde — 10/27  at  04:20 PM
Yeah I read it...I'm still reeling from it though...this is bigger than Al-288.



#7720: — 10/27  at  04:31 PM
Nature should know better than to say things like this:

"The discovery that Homo floresiensis survived until so very recently, in geological terms, makes it more likely that stories of other mythical, human-like creatures such as yetis are founded on grains of truth."

Pretty spectacular stuff, though.



#7721: — 10/27  at  04:34 PM
I don't see the big deal. So, we found some ancient pea-brained midgets -- BFD. What can concrete knowledge can we learn from this that has any practical application?



#7722: Jay Manifold — 10/27  at  04:36 PM
PZ, just a word of thanks for a phenomenal post. I was blown away when I read about it on Yahoo! News and was hoping you'd have the bandwidth to address it ... stuff like this is why blogging was invented.



#7723: DarkSyde — 10/27  at  04:46 PM
It's a big deal to those of who care about science Bob, especially human evo. It was thought that H erectus evolved from H ergaster when the latter radiated into asia. There were some signs that descendants of H erectus survived until anatomically modern homo sapiens came into that region ~ 50,000 although it was far from clear what happened. It's also known that neanders were contemporary with modern Hsaps in europe. This find has two interesting insights into human evo:

1. H flor would be the most recent contempories with modern humans. Puch much further past the most recent specimen and you're knocking on the door of recorded history.

2. They appear to have become dwarves which indicate that human evolution is subject to the same kind of plasticity we see in dinos, mammoths, etc which become island bound.

Mostly it's just cool becuase learning new, and in this case very unexpected, almost sci-fi type things, is what humans delight in doing; for we've been carefully crafted by natural selection to do so.



#7724: — 10/27  at  04:48 PM
That's right Bob, just keep telling yourself, "It's no big deal.....It's nothing important.....Stay the course.....This can be ignored".



#7725: — 10/27  at  04:49 PM
Sw33t!



#7727: — 10/27  at  04:57 PM
Well, Yes, I presume that you science-geeks are going hog-wild over these ancient pea-brained midgets, but, explain to me what we, the unwashed masses, learn from this.

Maybe it supports the theory of evolution, maybe it doesn't, but Who cares?



#7728: — 10/27  at  05:00 PM
Bob -

The same sadness that religeous people when athiests (like me) fail to see the beauty of their beliefs - That's what I feel when I read your post.

This is an amazing, beautiful thing, in the way that a tree is an amazing, beautful thing, or a star is an amazing, beautiful thing. Who gives two shits if it leads to a new geegaw; we've got geegaws a'plenty. Spectacular new insites into the nature of humanity are few and far between.



#7729: — 10/27  at  05:03 PM
You really don't need to know anything about Bob beyond what's in that last post, do you?

What a dull, lifeless existence it must be.



#7730: — 10/27  at  05:04 PM
Simply put Bob, this is part of the history of mankind. The more we know and understand it, the better.

I wonder if this anti-knowldege, "who cares" attitude is as prevelant in other countries?



#7731: DarkSyde — 10/27  at  05:06 PM
Bob you may be operating under a false pretense. It's not real important to us if you're excited about it or not. Capeieche? If you're not, no problem. No one is claiming you should be. But you asked why we were and some of us have replied.
This thing could end up being a hoax. What you learn in science is to be skeptical, to look for supporting evidence, to let people take time to examine the facts, to allow experts to convene and weigh the evidence ... Pardon the shot, but if you support Iraq and GWB, all these things are foriegn to you, so it's not surprising to me that you don't understand how fun this new find is for us.



#7732: Prashant — 10/27  at  05:15 PM
Do these papers have any evidence for the species living side by side with Homo Sapiens?



Page 1 of 8 pages  1 2 3 >  Last »

Next entry: Hide, George, hide!

Previous entry: How do octopus suckers work?

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college