Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Friday, April 22, 2005

I ♥ Vaginas

I like the town I live in. It's small, quiet, and a bit remote, all things that are sometimes constricting, but at the same time, it's an extremely comfortable way to live. Unfortunately, I'm also sometimes embarrassed by small-minded hicks. The latest incident in Morris was our theatre discipline's production of the children's play, Cootie Shots, which is all about promoting tolerance—that's a message some people in the community found offensive, prompting the cancellation of regional elementary school field trips. We've been reading people's complaints about the play with real disbelief.

"Oh, it's very obvious," countered Laura Carrington, a Morris school board member and retired teacher. "There's a script called 'The Parable of the Stimples.' The Stimples are people who are told that it's OK to make loud noises, but just don't make them in public. Isn't that similar to what, for years, homosexuals were told?

"Suddenly, there were more Stimples than ever. They mention that Stimples don't seem quite so 'queer.' That's pretty out front. I don't think it's the school's responsibility to promote the homosexual lifestyle."

What a bizarre interpretation of the play, and what a strange fear. I worry about my kids getting beat up at school, or being mocked and ostracized for being different, or of failing to work hard enough to succeed, but I've never, ever had a moment's fear that they might see a play and suddenly turn gay.

Carrington, who taught elementary school for 31 years, challenges the show's worth.

"It's not Cooties they're talking about, it's AIDS," she said. "Our job is to protect all our children."

It's all obviously irrational scare-mongering. This is not a play that makes AIDS desirable, nor are students going to get inoculated with viruses when they show up.

And then there's our other regional silliness: the "I ♥ My Vagina" witch hunt.

…after Carrie Rethlefsen attended a performance of the play "The Vagina Monologues" last month, she and Emily Nixon wore buttons to school that read: "I [heart] My Vagina."

School leaders said that the pin is inappropriate and that the discomfort it causes trumps the girls' right to free speech. The girls disagree. And despite repeated threats of suspension and expulsion, Rethlefsen has continued to wear her button.

The girls have won support from other students and community members. More than 100 students have ordered T-shirts bearing "I [heart] My Vagina" for girls and "I Support Your Vagina" for boys.

The Winona Daily News has plenty of silly quotes from people who are afraid of girls acknowledging the existence of their reproductive tracts. Another local UMM student blog, BMW for Peace, has been following the story since it broke.

But then, I realized I was looking at the issue backwards.

It's so easy to look at these stories and think, "Gee, what a bunch of idiots and cowards. Stupid ol' hicks." We focus on the "villains" of the tale and pretty soon we're generalizing to the properties of whole communities of backwater Minnesotans.

But hey, wait a minute, I am a rural Minnesotan! Ray Schultz, the director of Cootie Shots, also represents rural Minnesota, as do the dozens of students who are working on the play. Carrie Rethlefsen and Emily Nixon are rural Minnesotans. So are the swarm of their high-school peers who are buying those t-shirts. This isn't about wicked arch-conservative oppressors poisoning communities with their hatred, it's about smart people being bold and open and progressive. I don't even think the people opposing the play and the buttons are doing so with malicious intent—they're wrong, but they're talking about protecting their kids. It's hard to fault them for that. The objects of their fears are nonexistent, and they are being embarrassingly foolish, but their motives are pure, and they are actually incidental to the real story…which is that the next generation is showing themselves to be more open, more self-confident, and less constricted by the uninformed insecurities of the last.

It's good news, gang. Let's praise the forward-thinking communities of rural Minnesota and the heroes therein, who are working so hard for tolerance and pride. And let's not worry about a few entrenched folk who are defending, with well-meaning intent, old follies.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2201/4zOh5MXV/

Comments:
#22697: — 04/22  at  07:45 AM
Ah, that was a nice post. Warms the cockles of my moderate heart smile



#22698: Reed A. Cartwright — 04/22  at  08:13 AM
Now you know how I feel being a proud Georgian.



#22699: — 04/22  at  08:20 AM
Let's praise the forward-thinking communities of rural Minnesota and the heroes therein, who are working so hard for tolerance and pride.
Hell yeah!

It's great to hear that people are attempting to spread the good word (of tolerance), especially in the more conservative communities.

So, when is Morris putting on the play that says it's okay for atheists - er, the "spiritually challenged" - to come out of the closet?

Not that it would ever be allowed to run...

Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

-Jerry Garcia



#22700: — 04/22  at  08:25 AM
PZ, keep in mind that there is a difference between protecting your kids and trying to control them via censoring what they may see or do.



's avatar #22701: PZ Myers — 04/22  at  08:29 AM
One funny comment I heard: the play apparently has a strong pro-religion message, too, and maybe one way we could get the community behind it is if a bunch of us atheists started picketing it in protest.

David, I agree: that's why I'm saying their intent is good, but their methods are wrong.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#22702: — 04/22  at  08:36 AM
I agree, and I'm glad to hear you say that. Respect for one's enemies is, I think, critical to a functioning democracy, and rather lacking today. Yes, I know, some don't deserve it.

And yes, I know this kind of well-meaning "for the children!" wrongness can lead to some VERY BAD wrongness.



#22705: — 04/22  at  08:55 AM
...They are being embarrassingly foolish, but their motives are pure.
I'm not so sure how good their intent was.

Yes, they want to protect their children. But, sometimes I get the feeling that the parents are merely trying to protect themselves (i.e. from the "embarrassment" of having fostered - gasp! - a queer).

A situation where one's child ends up being a homosexual is often a "worst nightmare" scenario for these people, and I doubt it has much to do with how (un)happy their children would be (i.e. due to living the "lifestyle").

But, you're right. The most important point is that the parents' methodology is flawed. I mean, if you don't want your kid to be gay, don't censor them... be old fashioned about it! From birth, uncompromisingly pound into him/her that homosexuality is the tool of the devil!

Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

-Jerry Garcia



#22706: — 04/22  at  09:03 AM
David, I agree: that's why I'm saying their intent is good, but their methods are wrong.

Well, the intent of those who wish to prevent their kids from being exposed to anything positive about homosexuals may or may not be good. My grandfather may have intended to protect me from n*ggers by not allowing me to associate with them, but that doesn't make it a good thing. Rather, it makes it a lesson in perpetuating prejudice. We shouldn't excuse such acts by saying those who commit them may mean well.



#22707: apostropher — 04/22  at  09:11 AM
I ♥ My Nematode's Vulva



#22710: dread pirate roberts — 04/22  at  09:28 AM
i'm a bit confused. elementary school field trips were cancelled because of a play? and queers make loud noises in private?



#22713: charlie wagner — 04/22  at  09:46 AM
"It's not Cooties they're talking about, it's AIDS," she said. "Our job is to protect all our children."



#22715: — 04/22  at  09:53 AM
And telling our children that it's okay to not hate homosexuals is increasing their chances of getting AIDS?

Ignorance may be bliss, but it's a terrible contraceptive.

Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

-Jerry Garcia



#22716: — 04/22  at  09:56 AM
I have a front row seat to "The Vagina Story"; in fact Carrie's mom (a WSU Education prof) is standing at my office door at this moment (we're going to lunch).

Anyway, Carrie is an articulate and highly intelligent young woman (4 time ISEF participant, top %5 of class, etc.) The story broke after the WSU paper covered a talk by Susan Fahludi (sp?) here a few weeks ago. Carrie told the story during Q&A time and the WSU newspaper ran it when they covered the talk. Next thing we know the Star Tribune wants to talk and then the morning radio show plus the ABC affiliate in The Cities. Yesterday the O'Reilly Show called. She may pass on doing that one (I advised her to). Today, after everything else, our local rag finally discovered the story.

Greater Minnesota can indeed be great.



#22717: charlie wagner — 04/22  at  09:57 AM
laura Carrington wrote:

"It's not Cooties they're talking about, it's AIDS," she said. "Our job is to protect all our children."

Silly me. I pressed "submit" instead of "preview"...

Here's my comment:

Maybe it is AIDS. So what? All the more reason. If Ms Carrington is so intent on protecting *all* the children, she should be equally concerned with protecting the gay children as well, who make up about 10% of the population.
I taught High School in a liberal community in New York for 33 years and I witnessed many, many ugly and hurtful situations where students who were gay, or believed to be gay, were subjected to reprehensible harrassment, mental cruelty and even physical violence. We dealt with these as they occurred in a forceful manner, but we could never repair the psychological damage that these innocent kids suffered. It is a moral imperative that schools take steps to educate students in tolerance and try to prevent these kinds of attacks from occurring.
I wonder if Ms Carrington would have the same opinion if one of her children was on the receiving end of this brutality.



's avatar #22718: PZ Myers — 04/22  at  10:09 AM
So, have you told Carrie's mom that she ought to suggest applying to that wonderful liberal arts university on the western side of the state, UMM? We like students like that (I know, everyone likes students like that).

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#22719: — 04/22  at  10:14 AM
Sorry to jump on you, Charlie... Your first (attempted) post did seem a bit cryptic, to say the least.

smile

Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

-Jerry Garcia



#22722: Hank Fox — 04/22  at  10:37 AM
PZ, great read on the situation. Nice to find something hopeful in what we'd normally consider alarming.

Generally speaking, I find some of my most interesting thoughts happen when I turn around and look in the opposite direction from where everybody else is looking.

I think it is well worth actively opposing the luddites and falwellians and coulters and bushistas, but I continue to believe I see signs that they are, in fact, slowly and steadily losing ground.

Doesn't mean they won't cause a lot of pain and devastation and even death along the way, of course. But in the long term, a lot of the battles on which they're expending great energy and money are already lost.

Heh. Just today I read a quote to the effect that to oppose abortion and to not care for planet Earth is insanity. This was from an evangelical.

As another f'rinstance, I've also been thinking, for about a year now, that the debate over gay marriage (or civil unions, or whatever it gets called in the end) is already lost. Take your pick: It's going to happen, it is happening, it has already happened. The present-day wingers will entertain us all with their foaming and shrieking, but 20 years down the road, people will ask "What was THAT all about?"

When you get right down to it, the entire thrust of the right wing is reactionary. They have no plan, no vision, other than to turn back the clock, to stop what's already happening. The whole energy of their movement comes from Fear and Hate, the two ugly stepsisters of social progress.

There are moments when a slightly larger me steps up from the back of my mind and says "Oh, those poor frightened people. All this must be terrible for them. I wish there was some way to tell them that a lot of this small stuff is gonna work out just fine ... and that there are bigger things we need to concern ourselves with."



#22724: — 04/22  at  10:58 AM
Sorry PZ, Carrie's been accepted to that large school in Madison plus Mt. Holyoke and Smith.



's avatar #22728: PZ Myers — 04/22  at  11:43 AM
Nooooo! I'm too late!

I suppose those other schools are marginally acceptable.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#22736: — 04/22  at  12:17 PM
I honestly don't understand what's wrong with schools censoring "I [heart] my vagina". This is considered impolite in the U.S., and since kids are forced to be at school I don't think it's bad to enforce some level of politeness. I would also understand if the school administration banned pins about diarrhea, hemorrhoids, urinary tract infections, etc. It's one thing to prevent them from wearing the pins in public, but school is different. There are all sorts of rules at high schools that don't apply to everyday life, and I don't have a problem with that.



#22737: Craig — 04/22  at  12:19 PM
I sometimes find myself hoping that all of the insane uproar coming from the extreme right lately is a sign that they are losing in the long run... death throes or what have you. The problem is that if that IS the case, it will be years before we find out for sure... and when you're living through the middle of it it can feel pretty bleak.

Born in 1965, sometimes it feels like I just happened to be alive in time to witness the end of a short-lived bubble of mild enlightenment before society headed back into its norm, barbarism.



#22738: Sculptorsam — 04/22  at  12:59 PM
I honestly don't understand what's wrong with schools censoring "I [heart] my vagina".


Vagina=diarrhea?

Thanks for making the point, mike.



#22742: theyeti — 04/22  at  01:34 PM
Explain how you can work diarrhea, hemorrhoids, or urinary tract infections into political speech, and I will be greatly impressed.

Not to mention, what's the matter if it's polite or not? Here's what's rude. If you're walking down the street and see "I love my vagina," are you going to go up to that person and ask them to take it off? Even if you're offended by it? No, because you're a nice person, not anal-retentive, and making a scene serves no purpose. It's about respect, and I honestly think a lot of today's problems with youth could be solved just by showing them a little respect.



Trackback: I'd like this to go the the Supreme Court and... Tracked on: Frozen Tundra Blog (72.9.234.70) at 2005 04 22 13:39:16
...have them ban all sex ed. (Here's my original post on this..) The Winona Daily News becomes the last newspaper in the state to write about what's going on in their public school. Some students claim the school has focused on the butt...



#22746: craig — 04/22  at  02:50 PM
I don't think you can completely dismiss the school's concerns. They are probably envisioning things like seeing the boys come in next with "I love my penis" shirts...
Then "I love your vagina too!" and then "My penis loves your vagina" and the next thing you know you'll have t-shirts copulating on the classroom floor.



Page 1 of 2 pages  1 2 >

Next entry: Image processing rules

Previous entry: Speaking of science outreach…Cafe Scientifique!

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college