Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Friday, April 22, 2005

I ♥ Vaginas

I like the town I live in. It's small, quiet, and a bit remote, all things that are sometimes constricting, but at the same time, it's an extremely comfortable way to live. Unfortunately, I'm also sometimes embarrassed by small-minded hicks. The latest incident in Morris was our theatre discipline's production of the children's play, Cootie Shots, which is all about promoting tolerance—that's a message some people in the community found offensive, prompting the cancellation of regional elementary school field trips. We've been reading people's complaints about the play with real disbelief.

"Oh, it's very obvious," countered Laura Carrington, a Morris school board member and retired teacher. "There's a script called 'The Parable of the Stimples.' The Stimples are people who are told that it's OK to make loud noises, but just don't make them in public. Isn't that similar to what, for years, homosexuals were told?

"Suddenly, there were more Stimples than ever. They mention that Stimples don't seem quite so 'queer.' That's pretty out front. I don't think it's the school's responsibility to promote the homosexual lifestyle."

What a bizarre interpretation of the play, and what a strange fear. I worry about my kids getting beat up at school, or being mocked and ostracized for being different, or of failing to work hard enough to succeed, but I've never, ever had a moment's fear that they might see a play and suddenly turn gay.

Carrington, who taught elementary school for 31 years, challenges the show's worth.

"It's not Cooties they're talking about, it's AIDS," she said. "Our job is to protect all our children."

It's all obviously irrational scare-mongering. This is not a play that makes AIDS desirable, nor are students going to get inoculated with viruses when they show up.

And then there's our other regional silliness: the "I ♥ My Vagina" witch hunt.

…after Carrie Rethlefsen attended a performance of the play "The Vagina Monologues" last month, she and Emily Nixon wore buttons to school that read: "I [heart] My Vagina."

School leaders said that the pin is inappropriate and that the discomfort it causes trumps the girls' right to free speech. The girls disagree. And despite repeated threats of suspension and expulsion, Rethlefsen has continued to wear her button.

The girls have won support from other students and community members. More than 100 students have ordered T-shirts bearing "I [heart] My Vagina" for girls and "I Support Your Vagina" for boys.

The Winona Daily News has plenty of silly quotes from people who are afraid of girls acknowledging the existence of their reproductive tracts. Another local UMM student blog, BMW for Peace, has been following the story since it broke.

But then, I realized I was looking at the issue backwards.

It's so easy to look at these stories and think, "Gee, what a bunch of idiots and cowards. Stupid ol' hicks." We focus on the "villains" of the tale and pretty soon we're generalizing to the properties of whole communities of backwater Minnesotans.

But hey, wait a minute, I am a rural Minnesotan! Ray Schultz, the director of Cootie Shots, also represents rural Minnesota, as do the dozens of students who are working on the play. Carrie Rethlefsen and Emily Nixon are rural Minnesotans. So are the swarm of their high-school peers who are buying those t-shirts. This isn't about wicked arch-conservative oppressors poisoning communities with their hatred, it's about smart people being bold and open and progressive. I don't even think the people opposing the play and the buttons are doing so with malicious intent—they're wrong, but they're talking about protecting their kids. It's hard to fault them for that. The objects of their fears are nonexistent, and they are being embarrassingly foolish, but their motives are pure, and they are actually incidental to the real story…which is that the next generation is showing themselves to be more open, more self-confident, and less constricted by the uninformed insecurities of the last.

It's good news, gang. Let's praise the forward-thinking communities of rural Minnesota and the heroes therein, who are working so hard for tolerance and pride. And let's not worry about a few entrenched folk who are defending, with well-meaning intent, old follies.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2201/WTygucxH/

Comments:
#22751: — 04/22  at  04:15 PM
Then "I love your vagina too!" and then "My penis loves your vagina..."
And don't forget their biggest fear:

"My penis loves your penis."

smile

Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

-Jerry Garcia



#22753: — 04/22  at  04:20 PM
Schools spend a great deal of time worrying about control. Anything that will distract becomes and excuse for regulation. This is not necessarily good.

If the students are trapped with each other and therefore should be pasteurized for their protection, maybe trapping them together isnt the best way to educate them.



#22756: Dan S. — 04/22  at  04:45 PM
I would think the thing is that the school *doesn't* see it as political speech, as a feminist statement, but as high school girls working around school with buttons about their vaginas - as a source of disruption, innapropriateness, and general fuss . . .

"Explain how you can work diarrhea, hemorrhoids, or urinary tract infections into political speech.
Political speech, I dunno. Speech from politicians - especially lately - I'm not sure I see a difference to begin with . . .

Careful about assuming that things are inevitable. That may be true, but generally only if we continue to fight for them as much as we have been doing.



#22757: — 04/22  at  05:19 PM
The parents are right to worry about AIDS and their children. AIDS is a killer. But it isn't contagious except through unprotected sex, or other such close contact. If they are really worried about their children contracting AIDS, then they need to talk to them about the dangers of unprotected sex, and to realize that sex occurs, everywhere, whether they like it or not. Poor or no sex education, and prevention of access to condoms, is what spreads AIDS in the US, not the Vagina Monologues. Heterosexual intercourse is just as dangerous as homosexual intercourse, but they don't want to believe it.

If they're truly worried about AIDS, they should be making condoms available and providing real sex education. But they're truly ignorant, believe that their kids won't have sex, and that everything will be fine if they just keep their eyes and ears closed.



#22758: — 04/22  at  05:25 PM
And I would add Stan that a fairly significant number of those Morris parents have first hand knowledge of unprotected teenage sex. That is how they got some of their children.

The apples fall not far from the tree.



#22760: tristero — 04/22  at  05:50 PM
I heart my aorta.



#22763: — 04/22  at  06:15 PM
Of course they have first-hand knowledge. This isn't new in America. Remember Hester Prynne? But AIDS is a new factor in the equation, and a far more deadly one than has ever before been known. The fundamentalist belief in abstention is extremely dangerous, and will eventually kill tens of thousands of their children, if not more.

Fundamentalists, of any religion, are dangerous to society.



#22767: heinrich — 04/22  at  07:53 PM
Are these the same people that were opposed to Earth Day about 10 yrs ago because it was a heathen holiday? Of course now it's sponsored by ExxonMobil, so it's no longer heathen.



#22770: Eva Young — 04/22  at  09:27 PM
I think the other interesting example of a rural community being challenged on this type of issue, is the Brainerd area being challenged by Senator Paul Koering coming out as gay. To the senator's credit, he's staying in the area, and he's not getting intimidated by the bleatings of a bigoted GOP party chair who is threatening to run someone else against him in the Republican primary.



#22773: — 04/22  at  10:20 PM
Are these the same people that were opposed to Earth Day about 10 yrs ago because it was a heathen holiday?
Quite sad, indeed...

...especially in light of the fact that almost every Christian holiday is in some way rooted within paganistic history.

Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

-Jerry Garcia



#22786: — 04/23  at  02:52 AM
“Vagina=diarrhea?

Thanks for making the point, mike.”

Gee, thanks for twisting my words. I would also understand if a school banned pins that said, “I [heart] my penis”. Obviously, then, I think that penis=vagina. Just because you’re ok with the pins doesn’t mean that other people are, and I think that in high school, where people are forced to go, it’s reasonable to limit this sort of speech.

I still haven't heard a good argument for allowing these pins in school. Just for arguments sake, how is this different from allowing women to go to school naked to make the same political point? Would it be OK for a student to wear a "fuck bush" t-shirt to school? While I support the sentiment, I think that would be inappropriate to wear at school. If either of those examples are inappropriate, then the argument is not about "free speech" as much as deciding which speech is acceptable on campus.

I don't think the school thinks of the pins as political speech, anyway. As a previous comment stated, they just don't want the slogans to create a stir or to escalate.

On a related note, I consider myself a pretty liberal guy. I give money to liberal causes, including the ACLU. I gave money to the Gore and Kerry campaigns when I didn’t have much to spare. One of the main reasons I liked Kerry was because his wife rocked! I’m in favor of complete separation of church and state, in favor of gay marriage, in favor of abortion, and in favor of anti-discrimination laws of all sorts. And yet because I believe that speech can be limited in high schools in ways that it can’t in other places, now I think that “Vagina=diarrhea”? Get a grip.



's avatar #22849: Bill Ware — 04/24  at  07:22 AM
Rhea County HS put a dress code in place about a decade ago. Shirts and blouses of a single color with collars and sleeves, closed (buttoned) to no less than so many inches from the top. No "messages" (writing) of any kind on clothing or jewelry.

Lately they've allowed striped (polo style) shirts. Well, that's progress for you!

On the positive side, if you allow no messages, then you avoid the constant conflict regarding which are OK and which are not.

Craig, Your comment #25 beat me to the punch line and gives the term "slippery slope" a whole new meaning.

BTW, the Scopes "monkey" trial reenactment will be July 15-17 at the Rhea County Courthouse. Get your tickets early as seating is limited! wink



#22872: Alon Levy — 04/24  at  11:17 AM
I don't see why copulating T-shirts are that bad. They're bad for high school control of students, but that's not a good reason to ban them. I think that in a society where high school students have sex freely it's downright stupid not to let high schoolers do it in writing on their T-shirts.

Now, Mike, your two examples, "Fuck Bush" and showing up naked, aren't particularly good. I personally don't have any problem with "Fuck Bush," though you could argue that because it's political, it deserves more protection than "I [heart] my vagina." As for coming to school naked, there is a difference between coming to school naked and wearing a T-shirt with "I [heart] my vagina," mostly because the T-shirt is more of an expression of sexual liberation than an innuendo; "Come fuck me" messages are typically expressed by Britney Spears-style clothes rather than by T-shirt slogans.



Trackback: Why yes, that is a voter registration card in my hand Tracked on: Pandagon (205.196.218.10) at 2005 04 30 18:38:48
My boyfriend and I went to vote today for city council and on the smoking ban. My main goal was to cast a vote, but I also enjoy having the old ladies at the polling place size me up. The...



Trackback: People still believe this? Tracked on: Pandagon (205.196.218.10) at 2005 05 06 16:39:30
Well, with creationism on the rise again in America, it's no surprise that other ridiculous myths are rearing their heads. Fred at Stone Court alerts me to this story about a Michigan high school band that's been forbidden to perform...



Page 2 of 2 pages  <  1 2

Next entry: Image processing rules

Previous entry: Speaking of science outreach…Cafe Scientifique!

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college