Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Friday, June 25, 2004

I think he's a step-skipper, too

OK, this new ad by Bush, Kerry's Coalition of the Wild-Eyed, sends mixed messages. It's basically a pastiche of various Democrats speaking forcefully against Bush, spliced with Hitler footage from that rejected submission to MoveOn, followed by a brief shot of a placid Bush, tinkly piano music, and the slogan, "Steady leadership in times of change." I'm puzzled about what message he's trying to send.

  • "Yee-haa, look how deeply I've divided the country! I'm a polarizer, not a uniter!"
  • "Aren't those Democrats rude for pointing out how incompetent I am?"
  • "When you see chaos and ranting and Nazis goose-stepping around, think of me."
  • "Doggone it, I am a miserable failure—and I'm proud of it!"
  • "Isn't negative campaigning horrible? Look, here are pictures of my degenerate opponents engaged in it!"
  • "The worse I am, the more important it is that you keep me in office."
  • "Uh, well, there are a bunch of people who really don't like me, but it's not my fault. So vote for me to spite them."
  • "This is Step 8: 'Made a list of all persons we had harmed and became willing to make amends to them all.' We'll start apologizing in the next ad."
  • "The Democrats are beboppin' and scattin', and I'm losin' it!"

(George is reminding me more of George every day, I must say...)

(via Pandagon)


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/837/X9no9jkp/

Comments:
#3760: — 06/25  at  08:23 AM
Surely that has to be a fake...



#3762: Andrew — 06/25  at  09:44 AM
That's just bizarre. It just managed to make me even angrier at Bush, but then maybe it wasn't aimed at me. And it's not like Bush's own people don't get angry sometimes: http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/news/archive/2004/06/24/national1840EDT0761.DTL

It has to be a joke - it's not even coherent. And seeing Bush at the end with that ridiculous music is like the punchline. And besides, it is time for being angry.



#3763: Stacy — 06/25  at  09:52 AM
Maybe there is something to this ad. It makes Kerry look very lacking in charisma and emotion (which is true), but I'm not sure the Bush team really needs to be underscoring that "miserable failure" line.

I would guess most people in "middle America" don't know anything about MoveOn or Michael Moore and wouldn't know where those images are coming from.



#3765: — 06/25  at  10:30 AM
I don't know about that ad, but I fear that the Republicans are on to something that might really help them: pro-Bush backlash. With the Democratic convetion, and the F-911 movie, and all of the anti-Bush books out, some people who are not very politically active might get tired of the Bush beating regardless of the merits. I know it shouldn't be that way, but with the short attention spans and "everything is a game show" mentality that supposedly has infested our popular culture, Bush might get enough "sympathy votes" from people that aren't too keen on the issues. I don't have a good idea for what the Democrats could do about this, however.



#3768: — 06/25  at  12:30 PM
What. The. Fuck.
I mean, seriously, wtf? This is the weirdest ad I have ever seen. Are you sure this isn't a parody? It seems to me like this is an ad against Bush, not for him. I mean, the hitler comparison and all that. And the music at the end seems just... i dunno. Like the punchline, as Andrew said.



#3769: — 06/25  at  12:43 PM
I really would like to know if this is for real. It seems like it just couldn't be. That ad is very, very, bizarre.



#3775: obeah — 06/25  at  05:04 PM
I found this on the RNC site:

"Between Al Gore’s unhinged rants, MoveOn.org’s bizarre invectives and Michael Moore’s cinematic fiction, Republican National Committee Communications Director Jim Dyke wonders whether John Kerry now has a ‘crazy uncle’ problem. Listen to the operative portions from Jim’s Friday interview on Washington, D.C. talk giant WMAL."

http://www.rnc.org/News/Read.aspx?ID=4323

Looks like this may actually be the new talking point. The ad is bizarre, though. I don't know if they think it's a parody or what, but they're promoting it on the front page of their official site. Could just be red meat for the internet base, I suppose.

Damn, their blog doesn't even have comments. I wanted to see what people who go to georgewbush.com every day think of the ad.

spliced with Hitler footage from that rejected submission to MoveOn

This is so utterly dishonest, especially because they made sure to include the part where the filmmaker had inserted "Sponsored by MoveOn.org". Which, of course, all of the submissions said, even though about 1499 of them didn't get selected.



#3781: — 06/26  at  02:56 PM
What I wonder about is how they got permission to use that clip from a rejected Move.On ad. It wasn't in the public domain. Supposedly, it was submitted to Move.On by Democratic Party supporters. Then, though it was never run, Republicans somehow knew all about it and started blasting it. Now it turns up in a pro-Bush ad. Yet the makers of the ad aren't protesting its theft. Do you see where I'm going with this...?



#3793: obeah — 06/26  at  11:22 PM
IANAcopyrightL, but the snippet of the ad they showed probably qualifies as "fair use".

Here's the Creative Commons License for the Bush in 30 Seconds ads, by the way.



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: Fish courtship and sex

Previous entry: Throwing a damp blanket over big muscles...

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college