Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Monday, April 25, 2005

Isotelus rex, biggest trilobite ever

I have a couple of chunks of slate shale around here with some trilobites I collected years ago near Delta, Utah. The biggest is about the size of a fingernail, and most are much smaller. I was very impressed to see this monster, Isotelus rex, an Ordovician trilobite that was over two feet long.

Depending on your screen resolution, this image is about a third the size of the real thing, which is 700mm long by 400mm wide.

Isotelus rex
World's biggest known trilobite, holotype of Isotelus rex n. sp. (MMMN I-2950), articulated dorsal exoskeleton showing broken posterior margin of pygidium; Late Ordovician (Richmondian), Churchill River Group, near Churchill, northern Manitoba; note scale bar.

The paper describing this beast also had some discussion of other arthropod giants. In the figure below, #4 is the giant spider crab, and #5 is a large lobster. Those are the only two species in the drawing that are still extant, unfortunately.

big arthropods
Scaled outline drawings of large fossil and living arthropods; note scale bar. 1, Isotelus rex n. sp. from Late Ordovician of northern Manitoba, based on holotype (MMMN I-2950; 720 mm long, with reconstructed pygidial margin). 2, Reconstruction of pterygotide eurypterid from Silurian of New York State, based on illustrations in Clarke and Ruedemann (1912), restored to approximate length (anterior margin of prosoma to posterior tip of telson) of 1.3 m. 3, Simplified reconstruction of Arthropleura armata from Carboniferous of Scotland, based on illustrations in Rolfe and Ingham (1967), restored to approximate length (anterior margin of hypothetical head to end of posterior trunk segment) of 1 m. 4, Macrocheira kaempferi, drawn to approximate carapace length of 300 mm. 5, Generalized homarid lobster, drawn to approximate length (anterior margin of carapace to posterior tip of uropods) of 500 mm.

The first animal up there is Isotelus rex, and it's comparable in size to the lobster; in fact, the largest lobster on record would have had about the same body length as I. rex. The second beast is a eurypterid, or sea scorpion—a marine predator that feasted on trilobites. And the third is an arthropleuran, a kind of millipede-like giant. Some fossil trackways from these guys suggest that they might have reached up to 8 feet in length…imagine that crawling out from under your kitchen sink.

I don't think I've had enough seafood lately, because looking at that picture has me drooling at the idea of one of those eurypterids on a big platter, drenched in butter. Too bad they've been extinct since the Permian.


Rudkin DM, Young GA, Elias RJ, Dobrzanski EP (2003)The world's biggest trilobite—Isotelus rex. New species from the upper Ordovician of Northern Manitoba, Canada. J. Paleo. 77(1):99-112.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2210/IQEgIDFB/

Comments:
#22976: — 04/25  at  08:41 AM
http://njpaleo.com/article07.html
"Last of the Titans: Big Game Trilobite Hunting"

Enjoy.



#22978: Les Lane — 04/25  at  08:51 AM
Are you sure this isn't a picture of the Martian surface?



#22982: — 04/25  at  09:50 AM
Are you sure this isn't a picture of the Martian surface?
Now that you mention it, I honestly can make out two eyes, nose and a mouth...

...Wait! Me thinks I've spotted the Virgin Mary!

Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

-Jerry Garcia



#22984: — 04/25  at  09:56 AM
OOOOOooooooooooo...

Check out the pygidium on that one!



#22988: — 04/25  at  10:45 AM
Wait! Me thinks I've spotted the Virgin Mary!


Hallelujah!



#22990: — 04/25  at  10:52 AM
Trilobites in slate? Possible, but slate is a metamorphic rock, and metamorphism is liable to deform or destroy the fossils. Probably you have some shale with trilobites.



#22991: — 04/25  at  11:08 AM
"I don't think I've had enough seafood lately, because looking at that picture has me drooling at the idea of one of those eurypterids on a big platter, drenched in butter. Too bad they've been extinct since the Permian."

Too delicious to survive massive predation, no doubt. Makes one ponder, though-why didn't those scientists in Jurassic Park clone extinct creatures that we'd want to eat, instead of ones that would want to eat us? Very poor decision-making, in my opinion.



's avatar #22998: yami — 04/25  at  11:59 AM
PZ, what makes you think eurypterids would have been as yummy as lobsters? Crustaceans are pretty uniformly scrumptious, but I'm not sure an extension of that deliciousness to the rest of the phylum is really warranted. After all, we don't eat scorpion - but then again, I've never tried, so maybe we're missing out on something splendid.

Are there any extant meaty arthropods that aren't delicious? Has anyone tried giant spider or velvet worm or horseshoe crab?



's avatar #22999: PZ Myers — 04/25  at  12:00 PM
D'oh! Yes, of course....shale.

Now all the geologists are going to come over and throw their specimens at me.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



Trackback: Mother of All Mudbugs Tracked on: Pale Blue Dot (67.15.48.24) at 2005 04 25 11:17:34
Pharyngula marvels at the biggest trilobite ever found: I have a couple of chunks of slate around here with some trilobites I collected years ago near Delta, Utah. The biggest is about the size of a fingernail, and most are...



Trackback: Big and Crunchy Tracked on: stranger fruit (129.219.245.62) at 2005 04 25 11:17:39
In the spirit of bringing you large invertebrates ... over at Pharyngula, PZ gives a brief write up on Isotelus rex, an extinct trilobite from the Ordovician that is over two foot long. Think about it people ... two foot long. PZ's got pictures too. Ch...



#23000: — 04/25  at  12:07 PM
"I don't think I've had enough seafood lately, because looking at that picture has me drooling at the idea of one of those eurypterids on a big platter, drenched in butter."

Butter churned from mammoth milk ...



's avatar #23001: PZ Myers — 04/25  at  12:22 PM
I have no evidence for the flavorfulness of eurypterids at all. I'm hoping for a gig with the NY Times as their roving gastronome, once they invent a time machine (the Times is a natural place for that kind of research, right?). Then I'm planning to travel up and down the space-time continuum, eating everything I find.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



's avatar #23006: yami — 04/25  at  01:08 PM
Surely we can overcome the extinction problem with a little phylogenetics? This seems well within the realm of biochemistry...



#23008: craig — 04/25  at  01:14 PM
Trilobites were my favorite find when fossil hunting... you can find them in most of the creeks around here.
I think they are only second in popularity behind dinos - I'm on the yahoo trilobite mailing list and its incredibly active.

Unfortunately there are a ton of fake trilobites out there being sold - another reason that its more fun to find your own.



#23010: — 04/25  at  02:29 PM
After all, we don't eat scorpion - but then again, I've never tried, so maybe we're missing out on something splendid.

Try this,

Succulent Scorpion on Endive with Herb Cheese

Recipe here

http://www.californiawineandfood.com/events/scorpion-tasting.htm



#23011: m.christian — 04/25  at  03:18 PM
The write-up is fascinating but "Last of the Titans: Big Game Trilobite Hunting" by Geoffrey Notkin (http://njpaleo.com/article07.html) was delightful Thanks, arcticpenguin!



#23029: Joe Eaton, no relation to Dave — 04/25  at  07:29 PM
I wouldn't want to assume all arthropods are edible, let alone tasty. You may recall Richard Fortey's description in his book Trilobite of a culinary encounter with a horseshoe crab at a seaside restaurant in Thailand. Fortey figured this could be his best chance to find out what trilobites, his palaeontological specialty, actually tasted like. It was not a success. The horsehoe crab had been steamed, and the edible bits proved to be the large eggs inside the head region. The taste? "Even mixed with abundant noodles it was rancid and intense", Fortey writes. "I like to think that trilobites would have tasted sweeter."



#23033: — 04/25  at  07:46 PM
I wouldn't want to assume all arthropods are edible, let alone tasty.
Fine, fine.

Nonetheless, we musn't give up on the hope that some of these ancient arthropods might have been able to please us in other ways.

Accordingly... if William Burroughs' Naked Lunch has taught us anything (which it obviously has), it's that variable species of giant millipedes can be ground up into a paste and used as a powerful narcotic.

Are there any documented cases of any scientist (or hippy) who has snorted/injected a sample of one of the arthropleuran fossils?

If not... where can I sign up?

Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

-Jerry Garcia



#23041: — 04/25  at  09:29 PM
Trilobites, nature's snack food: crunchy on the outside, chewy on the in!



#23047: — 04/25  at  10:06 PM
Ooh... big dead bugs...

Maybe if eurypterids were soaked in butter and then deep-fried... yum.

I don't know about how eurypterids might taste like, though deep-fried mealworms are delicious and have a shrimplie flavour.



#23057: Ron Sullivan — 04/25  at  10:48 PM
Giant water bugs (they're from southeast Asia and unfortunately I don't yet know their name) are reputed to taste like Gorgonzola. I've seen them in the freezer case at one of the local Thai groceries. When I have a recipe and get my hands on some, I'll report.



#23070: Republic of Palau — 04/26  at  05:29 AM
/Homer.... "Mmmmmm, plastrons, *drool*"



#23074: — 04/26  at  07:03 AM
You'll enjoy eating these Trilobite Cookies

http://www.georgehart.com/trilobites/trilobite.html

recipe by Prof. George W. Hart



Trackback: Assorted Mysticisms Tracked on: green gabbro (66.197.156.133) at 2005 04 26 16:06:59
One So people have been blathering about the USDA's new dietary horoscope. I punched in my info and I'm a Grain with Beans Rising, with Mars in Vegetables and the Moon in Mac'n'Cheez. I must take care to eat extra grain-fed beef during the warm seaso...



Page 1 of 2 pages  1 2 >

Next entry: CSI: Cockroach

Previous entry: My first Café Scientifique

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college