Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Wednesday, April 13, 2005

Lobster vs. Sea Hare

Ah, Aplysia. Also known as the sea hare, Aplysia is a common preparation used in neurobiology labs; it's a good sized beastie with the interesting defense mechanism of spewing out clouds of mucusy slime and purple ink when agitated. I well remember coming into the physiology lab in the morning to find a big bucket full of squirming muscular slugs in a pool of vivid purple goo. And then I'd reach in to grab one, and they were all velvety soft and undulating and engulfing my whole arm in this thick, slick, wet, slippery knot of rippling smooth muscle…

Ahem. Well. Let me compose myself for a moment. I will say that I always thought handling Aplysia is an amazingly sensuous experience.

It turns out that I'm not the only animal that feels that way. A reader mentioned this fine article in Current Biology on Aplysia secretions, and it turns out that what it is spewing induces complex responses in predators—it's more than just an "ooo, ick, yucky" reaction to drive them away. Aplysia produces two kinds of secretions, a white, thick goo called opaline, and the intensely purple ink. Investigators paired hapless sea hares with a predator, the spiny lobster, in a tank, and observed what happened. Surprisingly, the soft little slug escaped from the spiky hungry lobster two thirds of the time, as can be seen in this video:

lobster vs. seahare movie
(3.4MB Quicktime movie)

Toss in a sea hare with neither opaline nor ink, though, and it was lunch more than 80% of the time. And it wasn't the purple ink that was critical, either: sea hares with ink but no opaline got turned into lobster chow 83% of the time.

It turns out that opaline is loaded with stuff that stimulates complex responses in the lobster. Some trigger escape responses, so the lobster reflexively flicks its tail and darts away. Some stimulate feeding behaviors, such as digging their legs into the substrate or clutching the frontmost pair to the mouthparts. And others cause the lobster to start grooming its antennae and mouthparts. The poor crustacean gets slammed with mixed signals.

Here's an analysis of just what is in that slime:

lobster vs. seahare movie
Composition of Opaline, Ink, and Hemolymph of Sea Hares. The three pie charts in the top row represent absolute amounts on the same scale; pie charts in the bottom row show the same results but on a relative scale.

Note the large quantities of taurine (one of the major components of familiar energy drinks) and lysine. One of the signals the sea hare is sending is that of food—it's called phagomimicry. It squirts out this viscous textured goo colored with inks and flavored with amino acids, so it's as if the lobster has been hit in the face with a Red Bull flavored cream pie. Then, while it is licking its lips and cleaning the glop off its face, the sea hare wriggles away.


Kicklighter CE, Shabani S, Johnson PM, Derby CD (2005) Sea Hares Use Novel Antipredatory Chemical Defenses. Current Biology 15(6):549-554.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2167/aWCLT5mb/

Comments:
#21780: — 04/13  at  01:43 PM
hit in the face with a Red Bull flavored cream pie

That's got to be one of the most evocative images I've ever come across in writings on natural history. Wow.

And I know what my confirmation word means! I feel so proud. wink "Uracil" what RNA uses in lieu of...guanine? U subs for one of the letters. That's always struck me as extremely weird, by the way...anyone know where I could get info on why that substitution exists.



's avatar #21786: senoritafish — 04/13  at  02:26 PM
I love sea hares. In my diving days, I used to pick them up and pet them like puppies (actually Aplysia vaccaria, the California black sea hare, really is about the size of a large puppy). My dive buddies always thought I was nuts.



#21792: WatchfulBabbler — 04/13  at  03:21 PM
Eric -- thymine is created by methylating uracil, as a kind of "tacked on" process (more proof of that pesky evolution thing, I suppose -- but don't ask me for the pathway, because I'm reaching way back in my memory here). So the question isn't so much why RNA uses uracil, but why DNA uses thymine.

Cytosine can spontaneously deaminate to uracil, which means that potentially you'll have C->U mutations appearing in RNA. Obviously, since DNA is meant to be long-term storage, you need a way to repair these errors. So, methylate U into T, and then you'll know if you find U, that it's actually a deaminated C.

Now, there are folks who post here who are actually qualified to deal with the underlying issues (or you can research them in a molecular biology or genetics text, should you have one available), but that's the quick and easy version: it's primarily though perhaps not exclusively for genetic stability.



#21793: — 04/13  at  03:26 PM
... and I thought I was sick in the head. ...

... Where can I grope one?



#21795: — 04/13  at  03:34 PM
Thanks WatchfulBabbler, that was helpful...sort of. I probably need more biochem to fully understand it.

But I _defy_ anyone to claim some sort of Designer would have knocked together a system like that. Truly weird.



's avatar #21796: PZ Myers — 04/13  at  03:44 PM
No point defying them -- they'll go ahead and claim it. They just won't have any evidence for it.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#21811: — 04/13  at  06:07 PM
That lobster looks like it's having a bad trip. I guess that will teach it not to try the brown mollusc.



#21814: — 04/13  at  06:33 PM
I've had a couple interesting experiences with sea hares. One was simply capturing one on a field trip one day and placing it in a lab aquarium. We thought it was the coolest thing ever. I always thought in mid-swim their "snout" resembles that of a St. Bernard galloping in slow motion, all flappy undulating jowls.

The other was a creeped out call from my parents while vacationing in Florida, asking me what the heck this "phallic" (as she described it...must have had it's "snout" extended) thing flapping around a pier was. I knew immediately what they were talking about. I suppose that should disturb me...



#21839: CKL — 04/13  at  09:03 PM
I've always found that the most interesting animals to handle are octopi. I used to have a really friendly O. bimaculoides that would climb up my arm when I put my hand in it's tank to feed it. The feel of the strength of the tentacles combined with the suction from suction cups is, to say the least, unique.

As for sea hares and other Opisthobranchia, I find them a little too creepy to handle. Though, they are often aesthetically pleasing with their bright colours.



#21848: coturnix — 04/13  at  10:24 PM
How was the chemical analysis done? This looks like a list of amino-acids, but were they free or were those really peptides or even larger proteins?

Any idea whatis happening on the lobster side of the story? What receptors does it have on its antennae, etc?



#21924: — 04/14  at  12:29 PM
it's a good sized beastie with the interesting defense mechanism of spewing out clouds of mucusy slime and purple ink when agitated.
So did this remind anyone else of Karl Rove?



#22032: Republic of Palau — 04/15  at  06:39 AM
Is it as fun as a bucket of bobtail squid? Oh dear, excuse me, I've come over all peculiar at the thought....

It must be more fun than a bucket of hagfish or even Sea Cucumbers. Sea Cucumbers out of water look just like a human penis with very bad acne IMO.



#22095: CKL — 04/15  at  02:37 PM
Hagfish are the most disgusting creatures I've ever had the misfortune to handle. So much slime....



#22099: — 04/15  at  04:47 PM
I worked with the nonswimming A.californica species for many years, so it was particularly interesting to see the A. braziliana species swimming off South Padre Island, TX. The undulation of their parapodia is fascinating to watch. We netted hundreds of braziliana under the causeway at night, where they were attracted by the lights. We dissected 1500 to collect various parts for analysis- it was a disassembly line. Out of the water, the opaline and ink form thick, mucousy strands that are best cut with scissors when trying to pour it out of your dissecting pan.



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: I tried

Previous entry: Truth in signage

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college