Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Friday, July 29, 2005

Massospondylus embryos

Echoed on the Panda's Thumb

Massospondylus carinatus Owen, 1854 isn't one of those flashy dinosaurs that has a lot of popular appeal to the crowds, but as you can see from the name, it has been known for a long time (first described by Richard Owen in 1854), and many specimens of various ages have been found—if you aren't familiar with what this beastie looks like, here are some photos of a fossilized adult and a reconstruction. It's basically your standard early prosauropod, but from the numbers of specimens found, it must have been a particularly successful species.

Now we know even more about it's life history, though, because several beautiful specimens of unhatched embryos have been discovered in Lower Jurassic strata from South Africa.

Isn't this little guy gorgeous?

Massospondylus embryoMassospondylus embryo
An articulated embryonic skeleton of Massospondylus (BP/1/5347A). an, angular; c3 to c10, cervical vertebrae; ca, caudal vertebra; ch, hemal arch; co, coracoid; cp?, cultriform process?; de, dentary; d1 to d14, dorsal vertebrae; f, frontal; fe, femur; fi, fibula; h, humerus; il, ilium; is, ischium; l, lacrimal; m, maxilla; mc, metacarpals; mt1 to mt3, metatarsals; n, nasal; p, parietal; pal, palatine; ph, phalanges; pm, premaxilla; po, postorbital; prf, prefrontal; pt, pterygoid; pu, pubis; q, quadrate; r, rib; ra, radius; s1 to s3, sacral vertebrae; sc, scapula; scl, scleral ring; sr1 to sr3, sacral ribs; sq, squamosal; su, surangular; t, tibia; u, ulna.

It's estimated to be a bit more than 8cm from snout to vent (the tail is not well preserved, unfortunately), and the authors think from its size within the egg and the degree of ossification that it was probably close to hatching. If alive, it would be small enough to hold in your hand, and would grow to about 5m long at adulthood. There are a few other things that can be determined from the skeleton.

The combination of the body proportions and poorly developed dentition suggest that the hatchlings may have required parental care. The diminutive ventral elements of the pelvic girdle, small caudal vertebrae, and relatively enormous head of the Massospondylus embryos suggest it would have been difficult for the hatchlings to move around efficiently. The virtual absence of teeth in these embryos is another indicator of altricial behavior. Only a single possible tooth fragment is preserved in the two skulls, whereas other delicate, loosely attached elements were preserved largely undisturbed. Even if most of the teeth were poorly mineralized or lost postmortem, they were not well suited for feeding. If this interpretation is correct, these embryos provide early evidence of altricial behavior in a nonavian dinosaur.

So, it would have been a clumsy, big-headed, big-eyed baby…or, as the Minnesotans say, "Oh, for cute!"

Another interesting observation is that the adults are clearly animals that can walk either quadrupedally or bipedally—they have hindlimbs that are significantly longer than their forelimbs, and would have run along on just their hindlegs, at least when they were in a hurry. The embryos, though, have fore- and hind-limbs of equal length, and would have had to walk quadrupedally at all times.

Massospondylus embryo
Reconstructions of Massospondylus embryos. (A) An articulated skeleton in lateral view; the horizontally held neck is shown at maximum dorsiflexion. The total length of the tail could not be determined; the estimated minimum length is shown. Estimated snout-vent length of the embryo is 8.1 cm. (B) An embryonic skull in dorsal and lateral views.

Enough specimens have been found to allow an analysis of relative growth rates of various bones in this species, and they've put together a lovely developmental picture of the animal. From these more lizard-like proportions, everything in the animal is going to grow rapidly, but the hindlimb and neck grow fastest of all to produce the long-necked, long-legged adult form.


Reisz RR, Scott D, Sues H-D, Evans DC, Raath MA (2005) Embryos of an Early Jurassic Prosauropod Dinosaur and Their Evolutionary Significance. Science 309:761-764.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2648/yksjHcTr/

Comments:
#33164: — 07/29  at  07:01 PM
Awwwww!!!! SO CUTE!!!!!

I want one. You guys need to get with the cloning, stat!



#33165: — 07/29  at  07:01 PM
So why were the heads so large? If it was because they had to eat large prepared food chunks to grow fast since they were relatively helpless, it seems sort of a circular requirement.



's avatar #33166: PZ Myers — 07/29  at  07:13 PM
The magic word is allometry. Human babies' heads are also disproportionately large; it's an issue of rules of growth for different tissues.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#33169: — 07/29  at  07:56 PM
'Massospondylus carinatus Owen, 1854 isn't one of those flashy dinosaurs'

Not for lack of trying! A powerful, lean, and nippy plateosaurid which may even have been able to run bipedally; remarkably balanced by its neck and tail, wielding wicked thumb claws which could be used for grasping, and one of the very few examples of Early Jurassic nesting (and the earliest dinosaur embryo found) to boot! What's not to love?

And the little chap's adorable! Excellent post. smile

-Schmitt.



#33178: — 07/29  at  10:16 PM
Thats really cool, paleontology was always one of my fascinations. One thing I missed though, how/when was it discovered? Was it independent from its long dead mother or did they find it inside another fossil?

-----
"As with all of ID, the important thing is first to have the concept. Production can then follow as a matter of course.” -Dembski



#33181: — 07/29  at  10:55 PM
The eggs were found in a clutch of six in 1978, stumbled upon during construction work in South Africa. I don't believe the find was associated with the discovery of any adult fossils, though egg fragments amongst the clutch suggested one had already hatched.

The embryos had to be extracted from their eggs and the surrounding rock, and the techniques and technology to do so were only recently developed. Two embryos have been extracted so far I believe.

-Schmitt.



#33182: — 07/29  at  10:58 PM
Apologies for the double post, but here's more on their discovery.

-Schmitt.



#33209: — 07/30  at  10:31 AM
So they find embryos that look significantly different from adult <italic>Massospondylus carinatus</italic> Owen, 1854 in certain dimensions. What is the evidence that they are actually the same species?



's avatar #33211: PZ Myers — 07/30  at  10:36 AM
Massospondylus is common in that area at that time, and they compared skeletal features that are not size dependent to determine that these embryos most likely belong to that species.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



Trackback: Massospondylus embryos Tracked on: The Panda's Thumb (66.15.48.88) at 2005 07 29 18:32:00
Massospondylus carinatus Owen, 1854 isn't one of those flashy dinosaurs that has a lot of popular appeal to the crowds, but as you can see from the name, it has been known for a long time (first described by...



#33224: — 07/30  at  12:24 PM
"The magic word is allometry. Human babies' heads are also disproportionately large; it's an issue of rules of growth for different tissues."

Ah, it's a general growth principle. I thought it was just my head that was swelled.

An unwarranted guess would then be that most bipedals have the same tendency for early quad drive. It is safer while taking a drivers permit, too. grin



#33282: jay denari — 07/31  at  12:36 PM
A quick question: Since this was an early dinosaur and the adult pic you link to clearly shows some sharp teeth, is it possible that this was an ancestor of BOTH carnivorous and herbivorous spp.?



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: Cheri Yecke is famous!

Previous entry: Under new skeptical management

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college