Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Friday, April 08, 2005

Morris: great school, typical rural community

After saying such good things about our students at UMM, it pains me to have to admit that our local community has a few, errm, problems. The university tries hard to reach out to the region and contribute to the local culture; as an example, every spring the Theatre Arts discipline puts on a children's play, and the elementary schools send students to see it. Last year, they had an excellent production of The Hobbit (even some of us semi-adults go to see these things, I will admit, and it was fun). In the current theatre season, they are offering a play called Cootie Shots, billed as "Theatrical Inoculations Against Bigotry for Kids, Parents and Teachers".

I was surprised to learn how far backwards our theatre department had bent to accommodate the Morris biases, though—the play is about tolerating differences, and after negotiations with the local principal, they had edited out any references to tolerance for homosexuality (I can imagine how much the director agonized over that decision…but he must have decided that it was more important to get the general message out, even if the specifics were diluted.)

Well, we just learned that the schools are planning to boycott the production anyway, after some members of the community protested. I know many of the townies are supportive and think the play was a great idea, but there are a few hateful, reactionary slugs lurking here. They like to hide behind the cover of the churches and so-called "values" and "decency". As individuals, they tend to be petty, spiteful, and inconsequential, but they speak as if they wield all the clout of GOD and AMERICA, and too many people, despite being decent and well-meaning themselves, are willing to surrender authority to anyone claiming the authority of those two powerful totems.

This is the message those people found offensive and in violation of community values.

COOTIE SHOTS carries the message that every man, woman and child deserves to be treated with dignity and respect - or, as one of its verses states, "You can't get cooties by being nice to someone different." The show's scenes, songs and poems create opportunities for children to observe and discuss sensitive issues in a creative, constructive context. COOTIE SHOTS is all about early hatecrime prevention and anti-bullying.

Hmmm. I guess I can understand how the town bigots would find inoculating kids against bullying and hate would be offensive—it would undercut their favorite tools.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2141/ht57gdSv/

Comments:
#21295: — 04/08  at  09:58 AM
Sounds like a great play for kids. We should do it here in Winona. WSU does the Vagina Monologues every year so this should fit in just fine. What's the best link for the UMM theater dept.?



#21298: — 04/08  at  10:17 AM
Teaching tolerance for those different from yourself? Sounds downright subversive. Wouldn't want to expose the children to that.
They must be taking their cues from the US Sec. of Ed. Remember how hard she came down on the ep. of Postcards from Buster? That's their idea of tolerance. But when the magic sky pixie tells you that homosexuality is wrong, I guess you have to listen, right?



#21299: — 04/08  at  10:33 AM
What specific objections have they raised after the homosexual references were edited? On the face of it, sounds like they really are slitting their own throats: "We object to this because it decries bigotry!"

Incidentally, the Secretary was on the News Hour last night. Totally dodged a question about whether it was official policy to discourage this sort of material--basically, she gave a version of the "Hey, I just follow orders" defense.



#21301: John Giotta — 04/08  at  10:37 AM
It's sad really. Being good your neighbor is now a tension builder.



's avatar #21302: PZ Myers — 04/08  at  10:41 AM
Here's the UMM Theatre Discipline page.

I haven't heard any specific objections, and I doubt if we will. Pinning the bigots down to specific objectionable phrases would make them look like, well, bigots.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#21303: — 04/08  at  10:47 AM
Theater Discipline?

Ve haff vays uf making you act!



#21314: — 04/08  at  12:10 PM
Well, we just learned that the schools are planning to boycott the production anyway, after some members of the community protested. I know many of the townies are supportive and think the play was a great idea, but there are a few hateful, reactionary slugs lurking here. They like to hide behind the cover of the churches and so-called "values" and "decency". As individuals, they tend to be petty, spiteful, and inconsequential, but they speak as if they wield all the clout of GOD and AMERICA, and too many people, despite being decent and well-meaning themselves, are willing to surrender authority to anyone claiming the authority of those two powerful totems.

Anyone else here been denounced by the anti-defamation league? I have, for participating in a production of Christopher Durang's Sister Mary Ignatius Explains it All For You---a satirical treatment of rigid, unthinking, abusive fundamentalist thinking that uses a warped version of Christian faith to justify itself. Yes, by all means, we must defend the Sisters Mary Ignatius of the world at all costs. One of us. One of us! Gooble gobble!



#21318: Jim Flannery — 04/08  at  01:31 PM
Wasn't that the argument behind the Spongebob protest? And its extension -- "No, Spongebob isn't the problem, tolerance is the problem."



#21322: ACW — 04/08  at  01:50 PM
There's still something wrong with this picture; we're not hearing the full story. Who decided not to take the kids to see the show? Find out who was responsible for that decision; it was a person or a small committee of people. Insist that they give a reason for blocking a message of tolerance.

If the answer is, "Certain parents complained," press the point. Find out who complained. Find out what their objection was. Find out why the decision-makers caved to a tiny fringe element.

This is a bug in the educational system. Act like a software engineer would: follow the chain of authority; fix the bug.



#21350: — 04/08  at  04:59 PM
Anyone else here been denounced by the anti-defamation league? I have, for participating in a production of Christopher Durang's "Sister Mary Ignatius Explains it All For You"---a satirical treatment of rigid, unthinking, abusive fundamentalist thinking that uses a warped version of Christian faith to justify itself.

Wait, the Jewish Anti-Defamation League denounced you for a Catholic play?

Or do you mean nutjob supreme William Donohoe's Catholic League, which works hard to suppress any realistic portrayal of the church or serious examination of faith? When Donohoe's not busy thinking about how all the Jews are promoting anal sex, that is.

I'm not a vengeful person, but I will never forgive Donohoe for getting Nothing Sacred canceled. Never.



#21353: — 04/08  at  05:10 PM
Wait, the Jewish Anti-Defamation League denounced you for a Catholic play?

Yes, indeed, they did, because we were defaming people of faith, you see.

Don't get me wrong, the Catholics were all over us, too (uh,. metaphorically), but the JADL took the time and trouble to ferret out the names and addresses of everyone associated with the production. At the time, we were working with an Episcopalian retirement home and there were a large number of old folks confused by the upset.

I think I still have the letter somewhere. I should ferret it out.



#21354: DarkSyde — 04/08  at  05:12 PM
And in other news, a mild mannered proffesor's house was burned to the ground, and a charcoaled lower case 't' was found in the front yard. Local investigators note that "This prafe'sr was a bit of rabble-rouser here in the community. He consorted with all kinds of internet weirdos, operating his "science", "Darwinist" and "constitutional rights" extremist web cult. It could have been anyone, and we're not likely to ever have any solid leads .."



#21359: — 04/08  at  05:32 PM
DS, So you've read "It Cant Happen Here"



#21362: DarkSyde — 04/08  at  05:52 PM
Heh. It's always tempting to believe it can't happen hrre isn't it DD? I think that's exactly how so many rational, secular people can manage to keep voting republican. Even those who love science. I have guy who comments on UTI from time to time who really does despise creationism. He's a thoghtful guy, definitely not an idiot and he knows creationism and other social conservative issues are BS. But he thinks he can 'carve them out' somehow. I doubt he thinks religious hysteria can really take hold, because it just can't happen here ...



#21366: — 04/08  at  06:25 PM
DS,
That guy needs to spend some time in my neighborhood.

When I was in finance all the 'money' Republicans really didnt believe that the theocrat Republicans were part of their party. 20 years later and I doubt they have learned yet.



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: The Ballad of Brave Lady Michele

Previous entry: Satan is a reptoid

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college