Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Saturday, September 10, 2005

My regional FEMA director…

Atrios had me worried—could the guy in charge of emergency response in my region also be a total political hack? Winter's on its way with blizzards and other nasty surprises. Fortunately, though, I discovered that the regional directory of FEMA region V is Edward G. Buikema, who looks like an experienced fellow.

In September 2001, Mr. Buikema was appointed as the Regional Director of FEMA's Region V. He coordinated FEMA mitigation, preparedness, and disaster response and recovery activities in six states: Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Ohio and Wisconsin. Since his appointment, he has overseen the response and recovery to 22 presidential disaster and emergency declarations that have occurred in Region V. The Department of Homeland Security designated him as one of the original Principal Federal Officials in December 2003. He has been involved in leadership positions in several high profile events including the 2004 Democratic National Convention and the Top Officials series of exercises. He is co-chair of the Great Lakes Partnership for Critical Infrastructure Security and Interdependence, a member of the Executive Committee of the Chicago Federal Executive Board, and a member of the Executive Committee of the Chicago Joint Terrorism Task Force.

Prior to coming to FEMA, Mr. Buikema was Director of the Emergency Management Division of the Michigan State Police. He was responsible for the administration of the state’s emergency management system and served as the State Coordinating Officer for presidential disaster declarations. He was an officer with the Michigan State Police for more than 26 years, with responsibilities ranging from law enforcement to serving as the governor’s authorized representative for nine presidential-declared disasters.

Mr. Buikema holds a Bachelor of Arts degree in Political Science from Calvin College in Grand Rapids, Mich., and is a graduate of the Federal Bureau of Investigations National Academy.


Uh-oh. I see that Washington state, where my family and my wife's family lives, the state with a nuclear submarine base, a major faultline and history of tsunamis, and active volcanos (my mom lives on top of an ancient lahar and my in-laws live in the shadow of Mount St. Helens), is led by a hack.

John Pennington, the official in charge of federal disaster response in the Northwest, was a four-term Republican state representative who ran a mom-and-pop coffee company in Cowlitz County when then-Congresswoman Jennifer Dunn helped him get his federal post.

Before he was appointed regional director of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), Pennington got a degree from a correspondence school that government investigators later described as a "diploma mill."

I wonder if mopping up coffee spills is adequate training for coping with pyroclastic flows? Maybe if the coffee is really hot.

I think it would be a useful exercise for our media to dig into the subject of the competence of federal appointees to important positions a little more.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2902/jOMI4AFl/

Comments:
#39516: John Emerson — 09/10  at  12:24 PM
None of the movers and shakers wanted to live out in the boonies.



#39519: — 09/10  at  01:21 PM
Since you seem to check the papers from WA state, you may be interested in what else was in today's paper. It is a review of children's programming:
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/artsentertainment/2002484451_kidfalltv10.html

The interesting paragraph about very BAD science education is this:

"In an episode of "Little Einsteins," the four main characters get their ship stuck on top of our very own Mount St. Helens. After playing a diminuendo to calm the volcano (OK, I'll let that go), the show cut to supposed video clips of St. Helens erupting — with a Hawaiian volcano's rivers of red lava. What, a 60,000-foot-high cloud of hot ash isn't good enough?"



#39520: Pinko Punko — 09/10  at  01:51 PM
The elephant in the room here is that 400 something other govt. officials got their management degrees from this place (California Coast or some such thing). Nobody seemed to jump on that. It appears the govt. investigated because so many people were getting their degrees there.

U have got 2 B kidding me.

Nope.



#39533: — 09/10  at  04:25 PM
While we're on FEMA, have a peek at the simulated disaster called "Hurricane Pam" that they went through. Fourteen months ago.
http://www.fema.gov/news/newsrelease.fema?id=13051



#39536: — 09/10  at  05:01 PM
We live in Seattle, and I am not happy to hear about this Pennington guy; however, there are so many problems that havne't been addressed here for so long, i.e., vulnerability of bridges, Alaska Way Viaduct, downtown buildings, etc, I doubt having even a top notch person would make much difference right now. We are heading for a real horror show if we have a big shallow quake nearby...
and since we are a "Blue State," I do wonder about suffering retributive neglect by Bush et al.



#39544: — 09/10  at  07:16 PM
Prior to coming to FEMA, Mr. Buikema was Director of the Emergency Management Division of the Michigan State Police. ... He was an officer with the Michigan State Police for more than 26 years, with responsibilities ranging from law enforcement to serving as the governor’s authorized representative for nine presidential-declared disasters.

Oh please, Dr Myers. Comparing this experienced bureaucrat to a guy who drove a horse show into the ground and has false credentials on his official bio is a contemptible example of playing the blame game in a time of crisis.

Typical partisan response I've come to expect from this blog - an emergency response collapses when any serious weight is placed on it and the first thing you do is ask how it could have happened.

-Schmitt.



#39546: — 09/10  at  07:57 PM
isabelita said "We live in Seattle, and I am not happy to hear about this Pennington guy; however,... I doubt having even a top notch person would make much difference right now. We are heading for a real horror show if we have a big shallow quake nearby..."

Then you understand that you need to be prepared in case anything happens. I know that many schools keep supplies on hand (especially after having children staying overnight during snowstorm in 1990). I also noticed that the Shoreline Costco had boxes of "The Ark" compact emergency supplies that could be kept in a car (they were near the bakery). Here is one website with suggestions for supplies:
http://www.metrokc.gov/prepare/preparerespond/english.aspx#kit



#39548: — 09/10  at  08:16 PM
Schmitt,
First, what's so wrong with the "blame game," as you so derisivly call it? I like to call it accountability.

Second, the resumes of Brown and Buikema are simply facts. They are important in that they highlight a "good" appointment and a "bad" appointment, which has had obvious consequences in Brown's case. Making the comparison isn't partisan, it's just common sense.

Finally, when something doesn't work the way it's supposed to, the natural course of action is to ask why. That way, should similar circumstances be encountered later, the damn thing will work the way it's supposed to. In this case, an obvious part of the answer to the question of why FEMA's response to Katrina was a failure is the lack of experienced leadership.

You can't avoid the facts or obscure the debate by screaming "partisan blame game!!" Why don't you instead spend your time doing something constructive like addressing the content of Myers post? Tell us why Myers is wrong for being concerned about the experience of our appointed leaders.



#39551: — 09/10  at  09:01 PM
For an insider's (or at least closer than the usual blogger) view of the Hurricane Pam exercise, there's

http://suspect-device.blogspot.com/2005/09/hurricane-pam-where-it-all-started-to.html



#39552: — 09/10  at  09:05 PM
Oh please, Dr Myers. Comparing this experienced bureaucrat to a guy who drove a horse show into the ground and has false credentials on his official bio is a contemptible example of playing the blame game in a time of crisis.

So, basically, you'd have no problem with the guy who drove a horse show into the ground in charge of your disaster response team. I mean, that's what I THINK you're saying here....



#39555: — 09/10  at  09:36 PM
OK, so you have someone experienced on the job, and I sit hear in Eugene, knowing that it's every man for himself if the Sisters 'bulge' blows, or if Mt.St. Helens belches forth again. But on the bright side, a nice man will be around with coffee afterwards. I wonder if he will expect a tip.

Who elected these jackasses anyway !



#39557: — 09/10  at  10:32 PM
Chaps, I can fully understand why your irony detectors would be overloaded given the past week or so, but I was parodying/mocking Mr McClellan and everyone else currently too slimy to let substantial criticism and bungling incompetence slow them down. Of course people should be held accountable, and of course life threatening incompetence should be pointed out. I agree entirely. My apologies if I've worked anyone up.

Oh one thing from Mr Crane:

Second, the resumes of Brown and Buikema are simply facts.

There's one potential problem with that statement, namely that Brown's resume doesn't actually appear to be factual. Astonishingly he seems to have several fewer qualifications that it claims, as reported by Time.

-Schmitt.



#39562: — 09/11  at  05:30 AM
Hmm, funny how the Chinese were able to move 800 000 people and 35 000 ships in time, before, a typhoon hits their coast, right about...



#39571: — 09/11  at  09:53 AM
ah, yes. I can see the irony in the last line now that you point it out.

Just another sign that i've been taking myself too seriously after all of this. Egads, but what idiocity and tragedy together do to my nerves!



#39583: — 09/11  at  12:43 PM
Maybe your FEMA regional manager really is better qualified.

Or maybe he has been more successful at faking his resume.



#39586: — 09/11  at  03:38 PM
I feel pretty good about our Region IX director, Karen Armes. She seems to have started her rise during the Clinton years, which may explain why she's only the Acting Director. I guess they haven't found quite the right political hack to replace her just yet.

However, don't think your regional director is going to protect you. The regional director for Louisiana, Gary Jones, has been with FEMA since 1983 and seems to have continued there throughout the Clinton years. (It's not totally clear, though -- it's possible that he left when Clinton came into office and returned when Bush II was elected.)



#39605: — 09/11  at  10:15 PM
Atrios had me worried—could the guy in charge of emergency response in my region also be a total political hack? Winter's on its way with blizzards and other nasty surprises.

FEMA shovels driveways??!! Cool!



#40211: ekzept — 09/15  at  11:40 AM
y'know, it would be nice if some of these feder-rah-lies anticipated problems for a chance, rather than doin' Flying Ming Vase-caliber engineering. ("Gee, Harv, that foam's been fallin' off ever since we first launched. Haven't lost a Shuttle yet.") arrr!

i mean, after all, s'ppose Yellowstone's twin magma domes do do into crisis, or that ostensibly magmatic bulge in Oregon does the inconvenience of turning volcanic. is it too much to ask in the discussions of how levees in New Orleans failed whether or not someone considered their design and response to resonant dynamic loading from a whopper storm? rather than simply "Oh, it'll only increase by 5 feet. We got 8", shouldn't someone be capable of some analysis? and look at that darn Congressional investigation into How We Failed New Orleans: scurvy bilge rats they are, m'matey. like th'Congress knows, having watched Mr Wizard or Bill Nye.



#40212: ekzept — 09/15  at  11:40 AM
"chance" --> "change"



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: Happy Birthday, Mary!

Previous entry: That is a great caption

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college