Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Tuesday, June 01, 2004

Nothing wrong with discussing evolution in school

There was an opinion piece in the Pioneer Press today that was both depressing and hopeful today. Here's the depressing part: gutless public school teachers and administrators.

A suburban Twin Cities elementary school invited me to speak to its students this week about my work. I have written several children's books, including a science book about our intimate connection to earth and life history. This book recently won the Minnesota Book Award for children's nonfiction. The school agreed to prepare for my visit by reading and discussing my books with the students.

The day before my presentation, the school sent me an e-mail. The faculty and the principal had discussed whether it was a good idea to share a book about evolution in their school and they decided that without much more in-depth discussion, it was not. They hadn't shared my evolution book with the students, and they preferred that I not share it as well. Later, on the phone, I learned that parents with certain religious beliefs would object to the presentation of this book.

The school was asking me to censor myself, but the idea didn't much appeal to me. I knew I would do a disservice to myself and other writers by agreeing to this surprise, last-minute request.

The author is named Lisa Peters, and I suspect that she must be the author of this book, Our Family Tree: An Evolution Story. I hadn't heard of it before, but it looks good and I'm going to have to order a copy—it's a children's picture book on evolution. There really aren't enough of those around.

But I was asked not to discuss this fascinating subject in a Minnesota school. Many other elementary schools avoid it, too. Some teachers tell me they wouldn't dare teach evolution. A southern Minnesota educator warned me in hushed tones that her town was pretty religious. I hear the word "touchy" all the time.

True enough. I know I had my preconceptions about progressive Northern American states shattered when I first got out to rural Minnesota. Creationists, anti-semites, weird fringe cults...they're all out here.

But that's all the bad news...I said there was also some hopeful stuff in the essay. I really liked the ending.

This widespread timidity comes, in large part, from ignorance. Elementary teachers reflect the general population: They don't know much about evolution. If they did, they would have captive audiences. They could tell their students that we share 98 percent of our genes with our closest relatives, chimpanzees. They could ask: Is it the remaining 2 percent that makes us wear platform shoes and dye our hair purple? What child would not be intrigued by that discussion?

While we wait for the new science standards to force teachers to bone up, here is a brief biology lesson:

Elementary teachers have backbones, inherited from the earliest fish in ancient seas. Teachers should use their backbones to stand tall and teach basic science. Tell the kids who object that they don't have to accept it, but they do have to understand it to graduate. Teach students about the wide range of creation stories, too, but do it during social studies.

Teachers have lungs, also inherited from early fish. They should use their lungs, take a deep breath and repeat: Evolution is not just one explanation for the diversity of life; it's the scientific explanation. Evolution is not a belief system that you take on faith; you examine the evidence for it and accept it or not.

Teachers have legs and feet, inherited from early amphibians. Teachers should use their legs and feet to politely escort anyone who protests the teaching of basic science to the front door.

And finally, elementary teachers have large brains, inherited from the earliest hominids. They should use those great brains to read more and learn more about evolution. When a parent comes in arguing that life hasn't changed over time, these informed teachers can continue teaching the facts: life has indeed evolved and here's the ample evidence for that position.

Knowledge is power and elementary teachers need more of both.

I've just got to say that writing children's books must be good training for writing with simplicity and clarity.

P.S. Ed Hessler confirms that the author of the op-ed is also the author of the children's book. I'll also recommend her web page describing the book—good stuff!


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/748/yk1kTg0V/

Comments:
#2900: Roy Sablosky — 06/01  at  08:43 AM
The best children's book on evolution I've seen is Virginia Lee Burton's Life Story: the story of life on our Earth from its beginning up to now, published by Houghton Mifflin. Originally written in 1962, a few details are sure to be outdated, but this is a lavishly illustrated and deeply moving account of life on Earth. It is structured around a roughly logarithmic time scale, so that the early "scenes" (it's presented as a sort of stage play) involve long periods of time, which get progressively shorter as we approach the present. Near the end of the book she's talking about days -- "Yesterday was a day to remember -- one of those beautiful warm spring days when one could almost see the plants growing." -- and at the very end she's talking about right now, this minute. Everyone on Earth should read this book!



#2901: John — 06/01  at  08:47 AM
It dawned on me as I was reading this post. Do you think the same law suite epidemic that plagues most of the professionals in this country is also plaguing our schools?



#2902: — 06/01  at  09:14 AM
John - is the Pope Catholic?
Public school teachers (especially special education and science teachers), administrators, secretaries, counselors, paraprofessionals, media specialists (AKA:Librarians), hell, even the cafeteria people, are all lawsuit paranoid.



#2904: — 06/01  at  10:11 AM
I'd never teach public school. Among other reasons, because each year before I taught evolution, I'd have to call up the ACLU and see if they had enough money to defend me from the lawsuits. How can you defend yourself from a dozen lawsuits on a $30k/yr salary?



#2905: — 06/01  at  10:12 AM
Ms. Peters is the author of the book you mention (and about a dozen more), beautifully written and illustrated. Her most recent book is geological verse which is both playful and wise. I agree with you about the powerful close. I'm not sure it has ever been said any better. Evolution in action! Furthermore, I like her use of another "E" word: evidence. She knows her science. For information about Ms. Peters, the book on evolution, her other work and lesson plans for the book on evolution, one for elementary school, the other for high school, see her web site at < http://www.lisawestbergpeters.com/ >.



#2907: Glenn Branch — 06/01  at  11:25 AM
Our Family Tree was reviewed in Reports of the National Center for Science Education 23 (5-6) by Lisa M. Blank of the University of Montana, who recommended it to "[p]arents and teachers struggling for an intellectually honest and yet engaging approach for answering young children's questions about how life began."



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: Is that a threat?

Previous entry: Submissions for the Tangled Bank!

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college