Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Wednesday, April 06, 2005

Old Man of Georgia

A fabulously interesting hominin skull has been found at the Dmanisi site in Georgia. It's old in two different and significant ways: the individual lived 1.77 million years ago, and he was ancient at death, almost completely toothless. He'd also been toothless for several years before death, judging by the complete resorption of the tooth sockets.

It's a touchingly human thing, that so long ago our ancestors weren't entirely brutish, but did care for the infirm to some degree.

Dmanisi skull
Edentulous hominin skull from Dmanisi, Georgia. a–d, Cranium specimen D3444 (a, frontal; b, right lateral; c, posterior; d, superior views). e, Mandible specimen D3900. f, Comparative computer-tomography-based lateral views of skull D3444/D3900 (coloured), the juvenile skull D2700/D2735 (light grey), and cranium D2282 with articulated mandible D211 (dark grey). Scale bar, 10 cm.

The National Geographic has some reconstructions of this old fellow.

imageimage

Carl Zimmer has a roundup of this week's hominid frenzy in Nature.


Lordkipanidze D, Vekua A, Ferring R, Rightmire GP, Agusti J, Kiladze G, Mouskhelishvili A, Nioradze M, Ponce de Leon MS, Tappen M, Zollikofer CPE (2005) The earliest toothless hominin skull. Nature 434:717-718.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2133/SBtXK5rO/

Comments:
#21168: — 04/06  at  02:07 PM
This is really intriguing and quite a bit of synchronicity for me. I was just reviewing the "Ultimate Survivor" special from the National Geographic channel, and they were arguing that Turkana (Nariokotome) Boy's survival through health problems argued for altruistic care for the sick in Homo erectus. The case wasn't especially well made, but this casts new light, of course.

Consarnit, I'm getting bunches of 404s everytime I try to look at Nature full-text or PDFs today. And I really really want this and the Toumai articles, like, yesterday. Hmmm . . . I teach over the border in a red state. Perhaps the antiscience apocalypse has begun and they're denying access to Nature.



#21172: — 04/06  at  03:02 PM
Interested readers can also go to Dmanisi for more info.



#21173: — 04/06  at  03:06 PM
Proof that yogurt was cultured 1.77 million years ago.



#21174: — 04/06  at  03:11 PM
That doesn't look like an erectus ... what species is that?



#21175: — 04/06  at  03:19 PM
This is cool also. Scott, according to the discoverers it is something of a transitional species between the habilines and erectus. Looks closer to the later than the former to me.



#21177: — 04/06  at  03:33 PM
Looks like a Nosferatu, to me. Heck, what do you expect from lawyers?

PZ, the little twist you put on the end was nice. It'll drive the creationists crazy.



#21179: — 04/06  at  03:51 PM
"It's a touchingly human thing, that so long ago our ancestors weren't entirely brutish, but did care for the infirm to some degree."

Aged meat tastes good.



#21189: Burt Humburg — 04/06  at  05:47 PM
PZ, am I on some blocked list of yours?

I'd have emailed this to you but I was afraid none of my emails were getting through. Take a look at this link.

http://www.cbc.ca/sunday/20050327-MacDonald_creation.ram

Sorry about the off-topic post.

BCH



#21191: — 04/06  at  06:47 PM
PZ, am I on some blocked list of yours?

I'd have emailed this to you but I was afraid none of my emails were getting through. Take a look at this link.

http://www.cbc.ca/sunday/20050327-MacDonald_creation.ram

Ahhh, yes! Finally the CBC puts up Neil Macdonald's report from the other week about creationism in Kansas. Thank you. I was wondering if the CBC would ever post that.



#21192: — 04/06  at  06:57 PM
damn. i am really glad my mother moved us away from Kansas when i was 10.

-kyle



's avatar #21199: PZ Myers — 04/06  at  10:38 PM
Burt, my software does have that Bayesian filter thingie which sometimes surprises me with what it judges as spam, but you aren't intentionally blocked. Send me another e-mail in the next day or so and I'll keep my eye out for it, and tell the spam-blocker that you are one of the good guys.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



's avatar #21202: — 04/06  at  11:05 PM
Old toothless' survival may not necessarily mean that he was freely supported by his friends or family. It may point to an exchange mechanism, known among chimps. He may have shared his catch with others and he may have enjoyed the soft parts of others' catch. Those must have been very good times, because during droughts and penurious times aged males (and babies) are always the first to die.

Quod natura non sunt turpia



's avatar #21207: — 04/07  at  12:56 AM
this story was also in the current issue of national geographic, along with a feature article on homo florensis



#21229: — 04/07  at  09:10 AM
I don't have the references (I probably read about them before I was on the internet), but I remember reading about two similar Neanderthal cases. In one case the person took a bad fall, and broke multiple bones, which would have resulted in complete helplessness for months. The breaks were all completely healed (albeit not properly set), indicating that he had been cared for for a long time. In the second case, the person had received a skull injury, which neurologists judged would have caused paralysis to one side of the body. The skull showed signs of multi-year healing, indicating that somebody with the use of only one arm and one leg had lived for years.



's avatar #21231: PZ Myers — 04/07  at  09:40 AM
Right. The important message, I think, is that these were people with complex patterns of social interactions. Sometimes they would have been ruthless, as jaimito mentions, and at others they would have been kind.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#21246: — 04/07  at  12:45 PM
That facial reconstruction is just creepily real. Seriously, I think that old geezer lives just down the street from me...



Trackback: A missing link found ... wait, there's two! Tracked on: Agylen (80.68.90.61) at 2005 04 08 10:54:25
Just found two interesting pieces of news on our origins. Here's to those creationists who are still babbling about the so-called missing link and how it supposedly reveals a hole in the theory of evolution. Not that I would expect any of them to be so...



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: I love our students!

Previous entry: The SciAm summary

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college