Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Sunday, December 05, 2004

Oooh, good company

It's that time of year again for the dreadfully misnamed 2004 Weblog Awards—the self-congratulatory self-aggrandizing but broadly named beauty contest for the right wing. It's very predictable: you know that drecky scum like Little Green Footballs will always bubble its way to the top, and that it will be so incompetently managed and designed that any clown who can write a perl script will bomb the vote, giving the winger nutcases a thousand opportunities to whine that the lefties are cheating again. As I mentioned on Norbizness, it really ought to be renamed the Wizbang Wacky Winger Awards so that there is no illusion that it is at all comprehensive. But do go vote there; they always include a few token progressives so they can pretend they are diverse. But don't be fooled. Last year, Michael Totten won the award for "Best Liberal Blog", which gives you an idea of how things work.

A better award system is the The EduBlog Awards, which recognizes the contributions of academic and educational blogs, and at least has the sense of perspective to limit their scope a little bit. They are also wise enough to have nominated Pharyngula in the Best Individual Blog category.

I'd tell you to go over there and vote for me, but gee, looking over the competition, there are a heck of a lot of really good sites listed there—many quality blogs, with no outrageous clinkers that I've found so far (unlike that other award site). So I'm going to suggest instead that everyone go over to The EduBlog Awards, browse around, check out all these interesting sites that aren't the usual boring blather, and vote for whoever you damn well please. I can tell my already excessive blogroll is going to have to bloat up a bit more.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/1645/9ud4CzTV/

Comments:
's avatar #10282: Ben — 12/05  at  06:35 PM
Or, better yet, don't vote for anyone. I don't need my preferences affirmed via herd mentality.

"The great trouble is that the preachers get the children from six to seven years of age and then it is almost impossible to do anything with them." --Thomas Edison.



#10283: — 12/05  at  06:41 PM
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAARRRRRGH!!!!!!!!!!!!! The "best designed & most beautiful blog" section must be a joke, because I know dozens of people who put up better layouts several times a year. "e-Literate" is okay, and "Projectories" is damn good, but the rest look like they were designed by artistically impaired ten-year-olds!!!! "Blaugustine" made me vomit! Someone tell me who picked those nominees, so I can SHOW HER SOME F*CKING TALENT!

Ahem.



's avatar #10284: PZ Myers — 12/05  at  06:54 PM
Hey, man, you're harshing my mellow.

I'm afraid to ask what you think of this site, which wasn't even nominated.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#10285: Lindsay Beyerstein — 12/05  at  07:23 PM
You got my vote, PZ.

Ben, I disagree. I love top-10 lists, Reader's Choice awards, Zagat, the NYT best seller list, and the like. These straw polls aren't epistemologically reliable indicators of quality, but it's often fun to see what people pick. I even like the The 2004 Weblog Awards because I've already learned about three or four good blogs that I never would have discovered otherwise. I figure that if the cost is minimal, why not harness a little distributed processing?

I'm mildly pissed off that neither Informed Comment nor Hullabaloo is doing as well as deserved in the 2004-W-sweepstakes. It's nice to see that Feministe and Matt Y are holding up well. Again, the important thing is to see it all as a fun and possibly enlightening party game.



's avatar #10286: PZ Myers — 12/05  at  07:29 PM
And one thing that helps in the Weblog Awards is that such godawful crap wins that it makes browsing the losers fairly productive.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#10287: — 12/05  at  07:55 PM
PZ, you got my vote.

Are the right-wingers employing Diebold technology to process their votes over at the 2004 Weblog Awards?



's avatar #10288: PZ Myers — 12/05  at  08:05 PM
It's a weird setup. Vote every day! No verification!

It's a strategy that pays off for persistent obsessives.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#10292: — 12/06  at  08:04 AM
"persistent obsessives"... you know, that describes a surprising number of right-wing pundits i can think of.



#10293: — 12/06  at  08:09 AM
Wow, Pharyngula is stomping! Congrats!



's avatar #10294: PZ Myers — 12/06  at  08:11 AM
Yeah, I'm getting a bit embarrassed. They're education blogs, so maybe with the start of the school week there'll be a bit more balance, but really, people, I won't be at all chagrined if you vote for those other guys.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#10316: ema — 12/06  at  03:48 PM
...vote for those other guys

Out. Of. The. Question. grin



#10330: — 12/06  at  05:42 PM
"I’m afraid to ask what you think of this site, which wasn’t even nominated."

Well, obviously Pharyngula isn't a masterpiece of visual design -- because that's not what it's for. Pharyngula is a biology, politics, and personal blog, and damn good at it; I don't care what it looks like as long as it's legible. I'm just mad because there are people out there who make design a big part of their blogs, and I don't see them represented in a category where they should really be the only nominees.



#10332: Evan Murdock — 12/06  at  06:22 PM
I agree with Aaron - your design is clean an functional; I would call it attractive, but it's not meant to be an art piece in itself. “Blaugustine” is almost unreadable, which to my mind would take it out of contention even if it were extraordinarily beautiful. But it's not. Needless to say I can't comment on its content.



#10401: Linus — 12/07  at  06:28 PM
Pssst. I bet I know who nominated you.



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: If Vesalius were alive today…

Previous entry: Now I just need to find a phonebooth…

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college