Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Friday, September 30, 2005

Tales of the X-Mice: how to regenerate

Life isn't all about squid; mice also matter. I've been reading about the MRL mouse, a lab-bred strain which has been discovered to have an unusual property: amazing powers of regeneration. They weren't bred for that, though; instead, they were selected for large size, and were then discovered to have a defect in the cell death gene fas, which made them a useful model for autoimmune research—they had excessive proliferation of lymphatic cells.


Ear-hole closure after 30 days. Through-and- through 2 mm holes are punched in the middle of the ear pinnae in both MRL (a,b) C57BL/6 (black mouse) and (c,d ) MRL (white mouse) ears. The holes can be clearly seen in the C57BL/6 at days 0 (a,c) and 30 (b,d ). However, by day 30 in the MRL (d ) the holes have disappeared.

One way to mark individual mice is by punching small holes in their ears (it sounds cruel, I know…fathers with teenage daughters also think it is a terrible thing to do). The mice of the MRL strain do something remarkable, though, as you can see to the right: they heal right up. There is no detectable scar tissue, either—these mice regenerate.

Regrowing ears might be a very big deal to a mouse, but not so much to us. However, their powers of regeneration go deeper. Damage their livers, their kidneys, and many other tissues, and they grow right back. They can regrow lopped off toes and tails. Here's the big one: take a fine wire, stick it in their heart, and burn a hole in it with extreme cold, a process called cryo-damage which mimics the damage of a myocardial infarction, and in the MRL mouse, heart tissue regenerates.

Whoa.


MRL myocardium regenerates. Histological sections of the mouse heart are stained with trichrome and the collagen is stained in blue. Five to 7 days after cryo-injury to the RV of the heart, the injury can be seen in both the C57BL/6 (a) and MRL (b) hearts. By 60 days, an acellular scar can be seen in the C57BL/6 (c) and near complete myocardium has filled the injury site in the MRL (d ) heart.

This is biology that's getting a little personal. My father died of a series of heart attacks stretched out over more than a decade, each one killing muscle and leaving its little web of useless scar tissue, weakening his heart step by step. What we wouldn't have given to bestow this small property of a mouse's heart on him…

Alas, it's not going to be easy to transfer this ability to people. The good news is that the initial studies have found that the genes responsible for the MRL mouse's predilection for autoimmune diseases are different than the ones involved in fast healing; there isn't a horrible trade-off, where better recovery from heart attacks means one is likely to come down with lupus (there are almost certainly other trade-offs, however; for instance, the MRL mouse exhibits a greater inflammation response to injury). The bad news? At least 20 different genes are involved in the regeneration ability of the MRL mouse. This is a very complex characteristic, not one we're going to figure out how to turn on in ourselves next week.

How does the mouse do it? Among the factors that block regeneration in us is the formation of scar tissue and the secretion of a basement membrane around reforming tissues in the wound site. This might be a good thing in the short term; it represents a rapid response to injury that could prevent infection and further damage. However, it also blocks reorganization and more plastic responses that are needed in order to regenerate.

Among the genes affected in the MRL mouse are a pair of metalloproteinases, MMP-2 and MMP-9, which are upregulated. There are inhibitors of metalloproteinases, TIMP-2 and TIMP-3, that are also downregulated. The protein-digesting enzymes are present in the wound sites, and busily break down the basement membrane, keeping the tissues labile. When the MRL mice are treated with a metalloproteinase inhibitor (the antibiotic minocycline), the rate of regeneration is greatly slowed.

The authors also report improved ability of the MRL mouse to regenerate from spinal cord injury; again, one commonly reported obstacle to recovery from neural damage is the formation of scar tissue, and these mice have less of that. There are some suggestive observations here.

These spinal cord studies demonstrate that the scar plays a major role in blocking the regenerative response and that even in the C57BL/6 mouse, axonal regeneration occurs in its absence. Perhaps the same thing is true for humans. And perhaps, without the scar, the same type of healing and regeneration would be seen in the heart.

An evolutionary lesson from this animal is that it represents a more likely example of how advantageous novelties arise: not by abrupt transformations of single genes, but by fortuitous recombination of smaller, hardly noticeable variants that, when they come together in a single individual, interact to produce a new phenotype.

This is an exciting model for studying mechanisms of regeneration that might someday be applicable to us. One other weird thought: I'd like to see a combination of the MRL regenerating mouse with the Mighty Mouse myostatin mutant—then we'd have a Wolverine-like superhero mouse!


Heber-Katz E, Leferovich J, Bedelbaeva K, Gourevitch D, and Clark L (2004) The scarless heart and the MRL mouse. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B 359:785-793.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/3027/mCRZwkV8/

Comments:
#42220: — 09/30  at  05:10 AM
The issue of scarring and regeneration isn't new. I saw some research on humans some years back in which they artificially slowed down healing and thus improved the skin tissue regeneration and reduced scarring.

I myself seem to be a mutant with naturally slower healing but reduced scarring. On the other hand I also have some immune problems and very thin skin which is easily damaged. So you wouldn't necessarily want my mutation(s).



#42224: DarkSyde — 09/30  at  05:38 AM
Good post. Dunno if this is accurate but I've read that mice often die of old age riddled with cancerous tumors; that if they lived longer the cancer would do them in. Wouldn't that indicate that activating adult stem cell populations such as--I would guess-- in cardiac regen reviewed here comes with a heightened risk of malignancy?



's avatar #42225: moioci — 09/30  at  05:53 AM
"Among the genes affected in the MRL mouse are a pair of metalloproteinases, MMP-2 and MMP-9, which are upregulated. There are inhibitors of metalloproteinases, TIMP-2 and TIMP-3, that are also downregulated...."

Interestingly, to me anyway, the matrix metalloproteases (don't know which subtypes) are involved in unstable coronary syndromes, by lysing collagen in the fibrous cap covering coronary plaques, leading to plaque rupture, unstable angina, and myocardial infarction. Thus if you had plaque to begin with, upregulation might be a bad thing, unless it interfered with plaque formation, as well.



#42226: John Timmer — 09/30  at  05:58 AM
Wouldn't that indicate that activating adult stem cell populations such as--I would guess-- in cardiac regen reviewed here comes with a heightened risk of malignancy?

Well, as long as the cancer and the regeneration are not linked genetically, there would be no heightened risk. The problem is that increased MMP expression, which loosens the connections between cells and their environment, also allows tumor cells to be more invasive, so there may be a link between regeneration and cancer aggressiveness. The important question would be whether MMP upregulation occurs specifically during wound healing, or whether it's general. If it's the former, it shouldn't up tumor invasiveness. If it's the later, there is a problem.

At the same time, this could be much about quality of life: would you rather have an active, healthy life due to a self-repaired heart or a lower long-term risk of cancer? If you're stuck in bed with a heart condition, the trade off may be worth it.



#42230: — 09/30  at  07:00 AM
Hmm, so a highly complex trait was bred into the MRL mice accidentally? You mean to tell me that didn't require generations of intelligent designer graduate students, planning every little bit of the new characteristics?



#42233: — 09/30  at  07:39 AM
Nick, I was going to ask why the intelligent designer didn't put the ability to regenerate into us when he made us. Was that some kind of oversight, or did the id have an ulterior purpose?



's avatar #42234: PZ Myers — 09/30  at  07:45 AM
The Fall.

He's punishing us.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#42237: — 09/30  at  08:09 AM
The good news is that the initial studies have found that the genes responsible for the MRL mouse's predilection for autoimmune diseases are different than the ones involved in fast healing; there isn't a horrible trade-off

That's the really astounding and lucky thing- as a card-carrying pessimist I would never have predicted that.



#42259: — 09/30  at  09:39 AM
Was that some kind of oversight, or did the id have an ulterior purpose?

The older generation needs to age to make way for the new. Maybe regeneration could prevent that. If no aged then it would be hard to get a teaching job. Think of the tenure!



#42294: — 09/30  at  01:38 PM
"Side effects include a compulsion to knaw on cardboard and cravings for cheese."



#42301: — 09/30  at  02:18 PM
It's a terrible shame that Douglas Adams died before this discovery was made. It would have been fun to see the look on his face.



#42304: bitchphd — 09/30  at  02:30 PM
MOUSE science. That's more like it.



#42305: pough — 09/30  at  02:31 PM
The Fall.

He's punishing us.


Don't laugh. Wait until Hovind adds this to his nutcase ideas on how we lived much longer before the fall. Then laugh.



#42306: Kagehi — 09/30  at  02:33 PM
Initially I thought this was a post on something I had already read recently. But leaves on one *major* factor the other article, from I think Discover Magazine, had in it. In the case of that study, I believe it was a mutation in only a single gene and they found that 'normal' mice could be given the same regeneration by simply injected cells from the livers of mice that had it, into mice that didn't. So, in theory making a human hot fix would be as simple as having one human with the trait, and merely introducing a retro virus to the liver of anyone else, which contained a 'hot fix' for the gene. Even if it only effected 1% of the cells in the injected liver, it would still preduce the same result.

Obviously this seems to be a different mutation, and one that is *far* easier to theoritically create a sort of regeration vaccine from.

Any priest or shaman must be presumed guilty until proved innocent - Robert A. Heinlein



Trackback: Mighty Mice Tracked on: The Two Percent Company's Rants (67.18.141.194) at 2005 09 30 15:02:21
Over on Pharyngula, PZ Myers has a fascinating post up on some laboratory mice who have the remarkable ability of true regeneration! One way to mark individual mice is by punching small holes in their ears (it sounds cruel, I know...fathers...



#42313: — 09/30  at  03:29 PM
Oh, my god! We are getting closer to my life-long dream of the everlasting beef tenderloin!!! Oooh, you think this could work with wine, too?



#42321: Bob Davis — 09/30  at  04:16 PM
Mice are fine and all, but what about self-repairing shoe leather? (or at least self-repairing cow skins that can be made into self-repairing leather shoes). I think the lab's intelligent designers should get right to work on that now that they've isolated the 20 genes in mice. After a short vacation, I suppose, but not more than a week, they've got work to do. The American public is waiting.

a modest experiment



#42384: — 10/01  at  12:39 PM
PZ, I believe that last sentence was supposed to read, "Mighty Mouse MYOSTATIN mutants." Yes, I nitpick.



's avatar #42388: PZ Myers — 10/01  at  12:51 PM
Yikes, brain fart. That's a major nit. I'll fix it.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



Trackback: Meeces to Pieces Tracked on: PhaWRONGula (72.9.234.70) at 2005 10 01 21:50:29
I'm called The "Contract" Cleaner—a master of my trade, But in Heber-Katz's lab last night my limits were displayed. A broken cage, the signs of raging rodents round the room...



Trackback: Tangled Bank #38: Science and Medicine Blog Posts Tracked on: Genetics and Public Health Blog (70.85.208.98) at 2005 10 05 11:05:14
Hedwig the Owl at Living the Scientific Life is hosting this edition of Tangled Bank #38. My brain and I are still on vacation, so I wasn't able to digest the incredible offering at one sitting....



Trackback: Superhero mice Tracked on: The College of Fools (216.73.114.134) at 2005 11 15 18:46:44
Terve kaikkille! (Hello to all! Yes, Finnish will slowly be slipping into my emails.) This is impressive: “One way to mark individual mice is by punching small holes in their ears (it sounds cruel, I know…fathers with teenage daughters als...



Trackback: Superhero mice - Part II Tracked on: The College of Fools (216.73.114.134) at 2005 11 15 18:46:55
At last, the promised summary. There will be some repitition from my previous email on the subject. The mice used in this experiment were an inbred strain (called MRL); this strain was originally selected for its large size and was later found to ha...



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: Martian weather

Previous entry: Anti-ID petition

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college