Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Thursday, June 16, 2005

Torture, PowerLine Style

As long as I'm dirty from wallowing in the sewers anyway, I thought I'd see what PowerLine was up to. Oh, the usual thing: making excuses for torture.

But wait, this is amazing. Not only does Hindrocket make excuses for torture, but he claims that our actions are testimonials to American greatness and high principles. You can almost hear the brassy, triumphant theme song swelling in the background as you read it.

By the way, there is a serious point to be made here. No one thinks that playing Christina Aguilera music, shaving a guy's beard off, and putting him in the same room with a woman are the most effective ways to extract information from a detainee. The reason why these unorthodox methods were used, obviously, is that the more effective, but less humane, techniques that have been used since time immemorial were banned by our civilian authorities, and the American military took seriously the restrictions under which they were operating. The mildness with which terrorist detainees have been treated stands as an imperishable monument to the greatness of the American spirit and the moderation of the Bush administration.

It's accompanied by a cartoon from the odious Chris Muir, showing a couple of prosperous Americans "standing for hours, listening to loud music, in the company of beautiful females." Oh. Guantanomo Bay is like an upper-class party now. At which you may end up dead or maimed, and men with guns don't let you leave, and you didn't want to go anyway but you were dragged there in chains. And Paris Hilton never shows up.

Here's the greatness of the American spirit, as defined by John Hinderaker.

imageimageimageimageimage

Makes a fella proud to be an American, don't it? It's so inspiring. And notice the sneaky implication in his comment…why, we're using less effective techniques, no doubt because of those pansy liberals. If only we could use the traditional, conservative techniques that have been used since time immemorial, think how the American spirit could soar!

I thought that the Book of Hinderaker was a parody, but it looks like it was a case of understatement, instead.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2434/w1xwQL2x/

Comments:
#29737: — 06/24  at  10:22 PM
Threat? From a possible question in a blog?

Only in the same alternate universe where Aguilera songs are torture.



's avatar #29740: Chris Clarke — 06/24  at  10:44 PM
his family (about whom he has now given information that I could turn into some very uncomfortable questions for him)

and then

Threat? From a possible question in a blog?

So. A racist, a bald-faced liar, and a disingenuous twit.

Anything else you want to tell us about yourself?

"I do not think we should antagonize the religious when it is not warranted, though I think we should be willing to do so whenever it is.”
-- Glen Davidson



#29742: — 06/24  at  10:57 PM
No, but apparently you want me to ask the question, so here it is:

When granny was looking after those kids, whose rice were they eating?



#29755: Alon Levy — 06/25  at  03:59 AM
Harry, let me ask you this: how did your state join the USA?



's avatar #29800: Chris Clarke — 06/25  at  01:44 PM
When granny was looking after those kids, whose rice were they eating?

That is your idea of a "very uncomfortable question?

I see.

A racist, a bald-faced liar, a disingenuous twit, and batshit insane.

Answer: I don't know. Not much of anyone's rice, from what I understand. It may be that they had access, in Canton, to locally grown food now and then. It may be that they were the beneficiaries of charities such as United Service to China.

You know, food donated and transported by people who didn't buy into racist delusions about "all people on the continent of Asia," who persisted in seeing the common humanity of people despite a few cultural differences.

"I do not think we should antagonize the religious when it is not warranted, though I think we should be willing to do so whenever it is.”
-- Glen Davidson



#29813: — 06/25  at  06:18 PM
It looks as though we (UK) are sending you (US) another rethuglican. Are the politicians merely feigning surprise over the choice of alliance given recent history?



Page 5 of 5 pages « First  <  3 4 5

Next entry: Volokh's question

Previous entry: Evangelical junk mail

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college