Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Friday, March 25, 2005

Tremoctopus: that's one big mamma, a dream for the macrophiliacs

Steff from Seattle sent me a link to a very cool paper describing an extreme octopus. One where the sexes are radically different from one another.

This is a female Tremoctopus violaceous. Note the scale bar, which is 5cm long. This is an immature specimen, and adult females grow to be about 2m long and weigh about 10kg.

Tremoctopus

This is a male Tremoctopus violaceous. Isn't he adorable? The scale bar is 1mm.

Tremoctopus

That is a fully adult male. It is 2.4cm long and weighs 0.25g.

The females are almost 100 times longer and weigh up to 40,000 times more than the males. That's an impressive degree of sexual dimorphism, and the authors report it as the most extreme example yet in animals this large.

Usually, this degree of dimorphism is ascribed to situations where females are sparse and hard to locate, and the male has become basically an extended sperm dispersal unit—once a male is lucky enough to find a female, he needs to cling to her and dedicate all of his time to his only important function, delivering sperm. A different strategy is proposed here. The tiny males have an effective defense mechanism: they collect stinging nematocysts from the tentacles of the Man-of-War, and hold them in their arms to flail at threats. Here's a closeup of the little guy's weapons.

Tremoctopus

This defense only works if you are small. Females, on the other hand, benefit from growing large, so that they can produce larger quantities of eggs. These two competing selection forces have produced two different growth strategies in the two sexes.

Incredible Shrinking Man

What else could this bring to mind but The Incredible Shrinking Man? Look at this still from the movie—the scale is even about right, with our one inch tall hero, and his 5-6 foot tall wife off-screen. And here he is even fighting off predators with a borrowed sting!

Of course, the one bit of verisimilitude they needed to add to the movie would be to have the little guy scrambling up his wife's leg to slap a sperm packet in her reproductive tract*. Maybe in the remake…


*One bummer for size fetishists: the evidence suggests that the male Tremoctopus, once he has fertilized a female, drops dead (although some seem to find that part appealing). This detail may have to be omitted in our hypothetical remake of TISM, too. It would be kind of a downer ending, not that the original's was any happier.


Norman MD, Paul D, Finn J, Tregenza T (2002) First encounter with a live male blanket octopus: the world's most sexually size-dimorphic large animal.New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research 36(4):733–736.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2080/hjD3yaMd/

Comments:
#19735: — 03/25  at  11:40 AM
Very interesting. It does seem a rather odd difference in size - can you give any good explanaition why it should be like this?



#19743: Mad House madman — 03/25  at  12:39 PM
seemslike a large difference. If americans keep eating the way they do (at least according to the weights of my patients) we may well live your analogy soon enough.



#19745: — 03/25  at  12:41 PM
PZ: I hope you don't mind, I posted a link to your place on TONMO.com.

BTW, isn't there an angler fish that has massive dimorphism as well? I think the tiny male actually fuses to the female's skin through his lips.



#19754: — 03/25  at  01:14 PM
Tiki God is right about the deep-sea angler. He actually becomes a growth near the female's vent. He loses all individual identity and all his functions are carried out through the female's blood supply. Very much like my first marriage; it too had a "downer" ending after successful reproduction.



's avatar #19786: — 03/25  at  02:10 PM
If Tremoctopus violaceous females are rare and hard to locate, it may be expected that males evolve efficient location organs, greater mobility, maybe luminosity to attract willing females, and other strategies. Increasing the number of males would do no good (evolutionally speaking) to the individual male Tremoctopus. I cannot imagine a strategy like that to succeed.

On the other hand, picking up stinging nematocysts as defense against predators, is an effective strategy, but why only males use it? At same point of their life cycle, females must be small and vulnerable too, and picking up nematocysts would come handy, so to speak.

Very interesting animals.

Quod natura non sunt turpia



#19798: — 03/25  at  02:56 PM
Awwwww CUTE!!! I want one!



#19804: — 03/25  at  03:15 PM
Jaimito,
the paper says that immature females defend themselves with jellyfish tentacles, but all of them observed to do so were >7cm. The authors hypothesize that
larger individuals are unlikely to be able to carry enough tentacle segments to defend themselves. Also, the increased size of suckers in larger individuals may render them unable to carry the narrow diameter Physalia tentacles without injury
not that they know how the little guys manage anyway. Look at the zoomed-in photo closely to see relative sizes, sucker disks vs. tentacles.



#19818: — 03/25  at  05:02 PM
The Spokane local news this morning ran a short clip of an octopus 'walking' on a pair of tentacles. It was cool to watch, although I dont know how rare such a thing is.



#19829: — 03/25  at  07:46 PM
There is a scene in Talk to Her in which a tiny man crawls into the vagina of a woman. It was related as a movie within a movie.



's avatar #19847: — 03/25  at  10:58 PM
Thanks, Steff. Now that I have read the paper, it is clear that it only summarizes the first encounter with this "extra-terrestrial" animal. I wonder how competition among males cause them to become so small. According to the paper, small size allows males to mature earlier and beat the competition. Is this strategy known in other species?

Quod natura non sunt turpia



#19858: CKL — 03/26  at  02:01 AM
Tiki,

The species is Ceratias holboelli.



's avatar #19863: — 03/26  at  04:42 AM
In Ceratias holboelli, is the male's life cycle shorter than the female's? In mammals, incl. ourselves, it is the females that tend to reproduce at a younger age.

Quod natura non sunt turpia



#19876: — 03/26  at  09:02 AM
It seems the juvenile paper nautilus uses
an entire jellyfish as a defensive weapon.

http://www.eyeonthesea.co.nz/weird/



#20278: — 03/28  at  04:16 PM
What, you make the analogy to The Incredible Shrinking Man but not Attack of the Fifty-Foot Woman? (Well, I suppose these women have only eight feet.)



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: A question about this site...

Previous entry: Old Brenner quotes always crack me up

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college