Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Wednesday, January 04, 2006

We're also mostly harmless

The h2g2 entry on the University of Minnesota, Morris is mostly correct—we are small and remote. However, it isn't quite flat. It's nothing like the mountains and valleys of the Pacific Northwest where I grew up, but we do have low rolling hills, and trees are not a rarity. It also omits some of the good stuff: this is the most sociable university I've ever attended, with much interplay and after-hours interaction.

Maybe that's an effect of the absence of much else to do here. We really do only have one single-screen movie theater, and few restaurants, and we have to drive roughly an hour to get to Willmar or Alexandria or Glenwood to find that sort of thing. So we talk to one another.

Oh, and some of us blog.


Since I was asked to expand on what it's like to "lead the life of a professor at a small liberal arts college in a very small town in the middle of an empty stretch of a big state," I'll say a little more.

It's a good life if you're the introspective sort. If your ideal evening is a good book and an easy chair, then you will not be stressed at all by small town life. If you look forward to shopping, a good restaurant, and a selection of different cultural events, you will go nuts.

I fit the former description, so I'm content. It's not that we're all reclusive bookworms out here, though; there are other advantages. Small town life means everything you need is in walking distance, so the day-to-day grind is very low-stress. I can walk to work, the grocery store, the coffee shop, the library…you can get by here without a car fairly well. The things we want are usually accessible via the modern equivalent of the old Sears Roebuck catalog: the internet. We do not have a good bookstore here, but Amazon keeps me going.

When I lived in a Philadelphia suburb, I had a one hour commute each way to work. What that meant is that after work or on weekends, the last thing I wanted to do was travel that route again to take advantage of the cultural amenities of the big city. They were there, and we did go to museums and the zoo now and then …but honestly, it was less common than we expected (if I were to do it all over again, I'd try to live in the city, but then the drawback is that if you have kids, inner city schools are often terrible.) Now when we want some big city action, we have to drive 3 hours to get to it, but here's the interesting part of the equation: we make that drive every couple of weeks, maybe once a month. That's about the same frequency that we visited events in Philadelphia. We traded one hour each way every day for three hours each way every couple of weeks; I think it was a good deal.

Another difference with the small liberal arts college vs. the large state university: in Philadelphia, I worked in a biology building and talked only to other biologists. I didn't regularly meet even with chemists, and English professors—why, they were an alien species found in distant buildings far, far away. Here, I have an office surrounded by geologists, mathematicians, statisticians, chemists, computer scientists, etc., and I regularly find myself in a conversation with humanities and social science people. We also have weekly get-togethers to eat home-cooked food (one way around the dearth of restaurants) and talk.

I think it's a great life, but there is one factor that can be catastrophically discouraging about it. If you are a single academic, you're going to be lonely. You're not going to have much in common with the townsfolk, and if you restrict yourself to fellow single faculty, the dating pool is miniscule. You're also living in a fishbowl, and everyone is going to know all about any romancing going on. If you have a partner, life will be a little better, but now you face another stress: the job market is also tiny. I think that if you asked most people here, they'd tell you that the number one pain of living in Morris is the two-body problem, and I wouldn't be surprised to learn that it is the major cause of faculty turnover.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/3667/ybrYL2BG/

Comments:
#56197: — 01/04  at  10:51 AM
Request: PZ Myers, could you post some thoughts on what it has been like to lead the life of a professor at a small liberal arts college in a very small town in the middle of an empty stretch of a big state.

Many people now are thinking and scheming and strategizing about where in the country to stake their lives, and there is always a tension between Big City and the culture and vivacity (and traffic, crime, pollution, housing markets) vs. isolated Small Town with its low cost of living, relaxed pace, but potential for soul-crushing isolation and boredom.

These concers are particularly salient for academics just starting out, since often one has to take the job one is offered, even if it is Galesburg, IL or North Adams, MA.

Any thoughts looking back?



#56202: — 01/04  at  11:16 AM
Man, I would hate to see what would happen to the author if he was sentenced to do some hard time in a really small town, say 18 years in Edmore, North Dakota, like I did. Poor fellow's head would explode as his vital essences dried up and blow away. Lucky that most people are made of sterner stuff.

BTW, if he is bored with the scenery in your neck of the woods, PZ, do you think he would go into a coma if he had to drive between Grand Forks and Fargo?



#56222: — 01/04  at  01:23 PM
"Some find this lack of nature disturbing."

Some folk have to be hit over the head with it to see nature, eh?



#56235: — 01/04  at  02:20 PM
I don't think I realized Morris was quite that small -- and with a student body that big a proportion of the population. (Do the 2000 students count in the 5000 total?) And I thought the place I did my undergrad had a high gown/town ratio (10k/50k).

Note to Tastant: take the Galesburg job -- at least their cinema is an eight-plex. And if you meet a geeky anthro major from Canada, be sure to make him work hard wink.



#56262: — 01/04  at  03:30 PM
I agree with PZ and justawriter. Morris definitely has a whole lot more going for it in terms of hills and trees compared to the nearby Red River Valley (includes stretch from Grand Forks to Fargo). I grew up near Grand Forks and attended college in Morris. I thought that much of the description of UMM Morris in H2g2 was quite poor. During my time at Morris I spent 2 years on the UMM's curriculum committee as a student representative, so I got to know many of the faculty. Like the author of the H2g2 article said, you can be involved on campus even if you so choose. I am not sure why only the Humanities department is mentioned. My experience in the Science department was great, especially the Biology department. Classes were often as small or smaller in my undergraduate science courses than they were in many of my Master's and PhD courses. In my own experience I also knew several very good history, psychology, political science, economics, education, and statistics professors. I am sure that there were many other great professors that I never got to know. The entire article seems to have been written by someone who did not really get to know either the town or the campus. The town of Morris is filled with a lot of great, friendly people. While many in the town were more conservative than the campus, the two enties (town and campus) existed together mostly in harmony. The most worthless statement in the H2g2 article was the following, "If you are interested in receiving a cheaper education you will find UMM to be challenging and reliable, but there are places to get a better education." What does this mean? Does it mean that if you are poor, than Morris is just fine for your type of people, but people who want to spend a lot of money can do better? Instead of writing this worthless sentence the author should have tried to actually provide some information for why s/he found the education to be lacking. My experience has been that often times the people the bitch and moan about schools like Morris are the people who want to have life just handed to them. Morris isn't the place to go if your idea of college is a wild club scene and you have always had life handed to you on a silver platter. However, if you find interacting with other friendly people entertaining, and you aren't afraid to work hard (maybe even get a little dirty), than you can come out of Morris with a solid education that is comparable to that of many if not most expensive private schools.



#56292: — 01/04  at  04:52 PM
What I want to know is, why is tuition at the University of Minnesota less for Wisconsin residents than for Minn. residents?

That aside, in addition to its high ranking among liberal arts colleges and universities, it's a bargain.



#56299: — 01/04  at  05:13 PM
Thanks! Just the type of perspective I'd hope to get. I'm glad you've found a good niche.



#56324: — 01/04  at  08:11 PM
How come Morris sounds a lot more interesting than Marshall where Dad taught at SMSC and I grew up. It must be the intervening 30 years. grin



#56329: — 01/04  at  08:50 PM
Plummet,

One of the reasons Morris sounds so interesting, as PZ said, is that Morris has a wonderful community of people at the University. Good Chemistry you might say. There are lots of small colleges in small towns, but UMM is unique in my experience. As Garrison would say, all the children are above average, ..... as are the staff and faculty.



#56331: — 01/04  at  08:54 PM
... and really, people need to get off this boring prairie thing. I grew up in the scenic Pacific Northwest, too (the part without concrete), and I think that much of western Minnesota is absolutely lovely. Wildlife, trees, grasses, hills, lakes, snow, sunshine, wind ... a beautiful place.



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: What was your high school biology like?

Previous entry: It's good to know…

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college