Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Tuesday, June 08, 2004

What a weird article...

Whoa. This article, Science Wars, that I found via Chris Mooney, has got to be one of the funniest things I've read in a while...and it's not satire. The guy, Lowell Ponte, means this stuff. There's a lot of the usual crap where he rambles and rants about all the left-wing socialist/communists who run science, but that's just tiresome, and Mooney already caught the amazing quote in which he calls George W. Bush a "genuine scientist", unlike all those, you know, scientists. I'll just mention a few small things that jumped out at me. Trust me, though, it's a rich article full of knee-slappers.

Science, for example, once appeared to be the pure pursuit of truth and knowledge by priest-like men and women dressed in white garments.

Yep, that's me. And Science is actually Mormon heaven.

One familiar name among the signers of this political attack is Paul Ehrlich of Stanford University. In his field of expertise Ehrlich is a giant. His expertise, like that of the late Harvard neo-Marxist Stephen Jay Gould, is as the world’s leading biological authority on certain species of bugs.

But..."bugs"? Ehrlich's specialty is population dynamics of butterflies. And Gould's research specialty was snails. "Bugs"? Does Lowell really want to reveal how stupid he is about biology in this way? And his point is just ridiculous—that because these scientists study small things that he, in his ignorance, belittles, they are not competent to discuss bigger issues. Somebody find me an elephant biologist, they're the only ones that count.

The Union of Concerned Scientists, a Leftist advocacy group, does not like sexual abstinence.

I can't say that I do, either. I had no idea that the Right found such joy in it, but I will cheerfully encourage them to practice it more.

But UCS Leftists hate guns in citizen hands.

Umm, wait a minute. This right-winger is ranting about abstinence and wants us all to love guns...where have I heard this before?

Oh, of course...suddenly the far right wing of the Republican party makes sense. Like their hero, Ronald Reagan, they think we're all in a movie, and in this case that movie is Zardoz.

floating head in Zardoz!

THE GUN IS GOOD! THE PENIS IS EVIL! THE PENIS SHOOTS SEEDS TO PRODUCE THE HATED HUMANS! WHILE THE GUN SHOOTS DEATH TO CLEANSE THE EARTH!


Here's how our right-wing heroes see themselves, as Sean Connery in a g-string with a gun and a scary mask.

Connery in Zardoz!

And see, leftists are all ineffectual hippies who wear funny clothes and wander around like zombies. Gay zombies.

Hippies in Zardoz!

I'm sure they're looking forward to the part in the Republican takeover where they shoot all the hippies, but where is the part where Charlotte Rampling is supposed to take off her clothes? That's the best part of the whole show!

At least Ponte does irony well, even if he doesn't realize it.

Sigmund Freud first coined the psychoanalytic term “projection” to describe those who accuse others of what they themselves do. A thief, for example, will tend to see others around him as thieves. And so it was that these two politicized groups accused President Bush of injecting “politics” into American science.

Well. Lowell Ponte accuses scientists of being a mindless gang attempting to monopolize scientific thought by imposing a political straightjacket on it. Then he brings up "projection".


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/776/DaIptk7G/

Comments:
#3087: Les Lane — 06/08  at  01:28 PM
A quick Google shows that Ponte learned his science at Reader's Digest. Perhaps it was a little weak on method.



#3088: — 06/08  at  02:12 PM
Unfortunately, Ponte represents the thinking of a large percentage of our citizens. I don't live in academia. Even a basic understanding of science is hard to find in suburban America. What passes as informed opinions is scary.



#3090: — 06/08  at  03:11 PM
Where are those images from?!?!?



's avatar #3092: PZ Myers — 06/08  at  03:56 PM
You've never heard of ZARDOZ? Bad 70s cinema by John Boorman?

You must rent it. I recommend viewing it with a group, with plenty of alcohol on hand.

I'm of an age to have actually seen it in a theater. I've always abstained from drugs, but it was an experience that allowed me to appreciate why dope was so popular in the 1970s.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#3094: Paul — 06/08  at  04:33 PM
I like this bit best:

"the official orthodoxy since the 1920s has been that, all else being equal, the carbon dioxide released by burning fossil fuel should be causing global warming."

That seems fair so far...

"Woe onto the young scientist who, e.g., dared point out that such burning also releases smoke and smog, which reduce sunlight reaching Earth’s surface"

So, all else not being equal then?



#3102: — 06/09  at  04:46 AM
Ponte:
Science, you need to understand, is in America today a mostly-socialist institution – and one of the most “politicized” realms in our society. Most science is now done with government grants or at government institutions such as state universities.

So government-funded = socialist? I guess, then, that the US Army is socialist. The FBI is socialist. Even the White House is socialist!



#3103: — 06/09  at  04:59 AM
Thanks for the link PZ, but that Zardoz review kind of freaked me out (Sean Connery must be more embarrassed about that one than Highlander 2).

Don't know how much luck I will have tracking down a copy here in Oz, so I will have to poke around next time I visit my USA in-laws.



#3136: — 06/10  at  01:00 AM
Golly, I hadn't seen that floating head for about 20 years. My cousin thought Zardoz was the ultimate key to life, but he ended up being somewhat insane.

The article in question demonstrates, above all, the tiresome "self-serving leftist" rhetorical technique--the self-serving leftist does nothing because he believes it will help anyone or do anything useful. Instead, the self-serving leftist scientist, in particular, spent all that time in grad school, slaved away at postdocs for years, and finally got some position that pays as much as a bus driver because he wants to suckle on the government teat.

Common variations include the civil rights/pro-choice/environmental activist, who actually keeps the negro down or destroys the environment or society or whatever in order to keep a cushy NAACP/NARAL/Sierra Club/whatever directorship.



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: Free beer!

Previous entry: A few more tidbits about Vernanimalcula

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college