Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Monday, May 10, 2004

What students know about physiology

I’ve just finished grading the comprehensive final exam for my human physiology class, and I noticed a few very consistent things. There were a couple of questions that virtually everyone got right.

  • They all knew exactly what causes a hangover (alcohol inhibits ADH, which leads to hypotonic urine and dehydration).
  • They all knew exactly when a woman was maximally fertile (mid-cycle, within a few days of ovulation).

College students. They know what’s important.

There was also a bit of a correlation in the answers to one slightly complicated question on hormonal regulation during the menstrual cycle. Most of the women in the class nailed it, while many of the men fumbled about and got large parts wrong. I don’t want to hear any complaints that it was unfair to men, though: I warned everyone that this was a category of question I’d ask, and I don’t think it is unreasonable to expect men to understand female reproductive cycles.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/645/NWQR5GDT/

Comments:
#2382: Bill Tozier — 05/10  at  02:12 PM
You're always sending me back to think of old exam questions and the answers we got -- ought to be a blog category.

Right now, you've called forth memories of a tricky question (so we thought, in the early 1990s) about caffeine desensitization and G protein mediated signaling. It was truly comprehensive, involving bits about the transcription, translation, routing, and activation of the receptors, and how caffeine dose eventually led to increased expression.

Turned out the students aced it. Coffee, after all, is up there with fertility and ethanol on their favorite chemicals lists....



's avatar #2383: PZ Myers — 05/10  at  02:22 PM
I really ought to offer a course on the things that students find really important:

* Sex
* Alcohol
* Coffee
* Pie
* Gambling (statistics, probability)
* Wheedling (psychology)

I think it would have to be a two-semester series. Sex in the first semester, everything else in the second.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#2384: — 05/10  at  02:25 PM
Pie? I would have expected ice cream to be up there.



's avatar #2385: PZ Myers — 05/10  at  03:16 PM
Well, it's Minnesota. Most of our school year is spent locked inside a glacier.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#2386: Reed A. Cartwright — 05/10  at  04:18 PM
Perhaps, PZ, you could use such a class to indoctrinate them into evilution?



's avatar #2387: PZ Myers — 05/10  at  05:04 PM
Oh, how I chafed under the restrictive topic in this class: it was exclusively human physiology. If it had been comparative physiology, it would have been much more fun. As it is, I did try to sneak in regular doses of developmental biology to induce them to take my db course next fall—which is heavily loaded with evo-devo stuff.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#2388: Allyson M Dyar — 05/10  at  05:56 PM
Well, pooh on your students.

Hey, when I lived in Iceland, I still ate ice cream! smile

Oh, and if I might say this since this is my first comment, I do love your blog and I wish I'd had you as my teacher when I was taking Biology in college.

(For the record, I do have a BS in Biology, but don't get to do too much with it except say I have it. -g-)



#2389: — 05/10  at  08:27 PM
Welcome to the Pharyngula lurkers' club, Allyson! I don't have a BS, although anything I say about biology is likely to be BS. wink

Speaking of the biology of hangovers, which writer remarked that yeast's first evolutionary priority was to develop the capacity to synthesize alcohol?



#2390: Courtney — 05/10  at  09:18 PM

* Sex
* Alcohol
* Coffee
* Pie
* Gambling (statistics, probability)
* Wheedling (psychology)


If you did that, you'd become a super popular prof. ;)

Except, I'd do:

*Sex (including pheremones)
*Alcohol
*Caffeine (because we don't all drink coffee)
*Marijuana (because we've all tried it)
*Gambling (esp poker & the lottery)


Wheedling is soooo high school. ;)



#2391: — 05/11  at  10:39 AM
No ice cream?

Whenever my Ph.D. advisor took us out for ice cream, he always got good grant news.

I always wondered why he didn't take us out for ice cream more often.



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: Creationist genetics

Previous entry: I've been consistent, at least

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college