Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Wednesday, December 29, 2004

What's Really Important?

Deep under the now scenic, placid blue seas of southeast Asia, a geological horror is forming of gargantuan proportions. One which will leave its novel signature for eons in the rocky column. A new layer of strata has been laid down, but this deposit is uniquely macabre. It's a hominid bone-bed. Mixed in with the newly forming sandstones, limestones, shales, and chalk, are the remains of a civilization. Homes, trees, crops, cars, factories. And the unthinkable human toll: 300,000* dead men, women, and children. The last thoughts they had must have been rife with stark raving terror. At least tonight they lay peacefully, no longer wide eyed in fear, the final echo of their lives flickering through their oxygen deprived psyche. At least that part is over, for them; back in the earth from which we all, ultimately, arise and then return.

On the altered coastlines of Sumatra, Indonesia and nearby countries, whole villages are missing; there's just water, sand, and debris where entire towns once stood. To estimate the dead, local officials, the few who are left, are having to consult maps with GPS coordinates and then looking to see if there's still a community at that location. If there is nothing but rubble, or, even more startling, a pristine clean beach with no trace of survivors or homes, shops, and streets, they take the last population reported, and add it to the growing list of victims. It's that bad.

And, it's not over. This tragedy isn't over by a long shot. More will die, perhaps as many as have already perished in the blink of one bright Sunday morning, perhaps more. There are tens of millions of stunned, injured, and homeless people, some dying as I write this, stumbling around aimlessly in mosquito-infested swamps looking desperately for food, for clothing, for their loved ones; hoping against hope to find anyone they know. They are looking for a way to live. They are fighting for their very right to exist. Sadly, those survivors are going to be cut down in great numbers from the ensuing starvation, disease, lack of medicine, and the inevitable, panic-induced violence.

Many of the affected countries have a high population of Muslims. These tend to be the moderate Muslim nations. The cultures which have helped us the most in the fight against Al Qaeda. These are the very people who we would like to enlist in helping us fight international Islamic Militants, and the ones who are most likely to cooperate in doing so. They are industrious people, known for their commitment to science and education. But the real reason we have to help is not because of what they can do for us, but because of what we can do for them; our brothers and sisters, our grand nieces and maternal nephews, in our great family. They need help.

Wouldn't you think this catastrophe would be the kind of thing we, as a nation, would want to reach out to and soften, anyway we can? Even if it's not something that's going to directly benefit us? That we'd want to lend a hand, no matter who the victims are? If not now, when? If not for this, what for? If not for political gain, for simple humanity? For decency?

FOR VALUES?

Because we are all human, and this is utter human devastation. This could have been us. It's human misery on the scale of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. This is 100 Titanics. This is twice the Vietnam War. And it's something we could make an enormous difference in, the most serious kind of difference, the difference between life and death, for thousands of our fellow travelers rocketing around our local star on this small world we all share.

I don't want to sound like I'm trying to make a political statement here, this isn't the appropriate place for that kind of thing. This disaster transcends petty politics, no doubt. But, I have to say honestly, I'm effin ashamed of my country. We first pledged 15 million, and then increased it to 40 million. Forty-Million dollars ... Sounds like a lot? To put that in perspective, we're going to spend 40 to 50 million in Washington, DC, in one afternoon, on the Presidential Inauguration. To give our pledge some context, we're spending about 100 to 200 million dollars a day in Iraq. We spend damn near 40 million for beer, chips, and soft drinks in this country every day.

Our leaders, the leaders of the richest, most prosperous nation on Earth, could have been flown in on Air Force One and other senior executive aircraft to the region in a few hours, check-book in hand, to respectfully represent our sorrow, our grief, and most important, our life-saving generosity. Surely that would have made a better photo-op than a carrier landing. They could have shown the Muslim World and the international community what the America you and I know is really about, and done so in a positive, charitable way. Instead, our White House is on vacation ... Godamn, our response so far makes me feel ashamed to be an American. It's not just poor leadership and poor PR, it's immoral.

And you know what? I don't have to put up with that shit. I don't have to let those assholes speak for me. I just gave 50 dollars to Red Crescent, earmarked to save my brothers lives, and I feel pretty damn good about doing it! I felt so good about it, I gave another fifty for those of you who may be struggling. It's a few days after Christmas, it would be truthful for me to say that things are a little tighter than usual around DarkSyde Manor. But that's a cop-out. I can easily afford it. Hell, by not eating fast food at lunch for a month I can afford it. Save lives and avoid fast food for a month? That's a bargain I can't pass up.

I realize we have a lot of students, single moms, single dads, folks who are sick, and on fixed incomes, reading this site and making up this wonderful zany community we call Pharyngula. But if you can give a little, please think about it. Not everyone can afford to give a hundred bucks, not everyone can afford to give anything at all, but if you can spare ten dollars, get off your duff and do it. Just because our leaders think billions in corporate welfare, and mega buck weapons systems to kill people, are better ways to spend money than saving the helpless victims of disaster, doesn't mean I have to let them speak for me. And I won't.

Lots of ways you can contribute are being tracked by The Command Post. They're really on top of this, and I think they deserve some recogniton. Even if you can't spare the change, maybe some of us could go visit their Blog and say howdy to them, and let them know how we feel.

Update: Crooked Timber has a deal up concerning Amazon for donations. Hat Tip: Isabel who also has some additional donation info
on her Blog.

UPDATE: Death Toll now estimated at over 200,000, expected to rise to perhaps 400,000. Several medium sized cities in Indonesia cannot be located reliably. No survivors see in aeriel surveys.

Update: In comments JBarker asked: I’m still seeing 124,000 dead on the BBC. Are these extrapolations taking into account starvation and disease in the coming weeks? Or are they still just referring to the immediate tsunami death toll?

Last night on MSNBC's News Program Countdown with Keith Olbler, several local reporters were discussing an aerial reconnaissance survey of the hardest hit area in Indonesia. Apparently, at least three medium sized cities, with population in the 100,000 or so each, are basically ... gone. They reported no structures left standing, no survivors sighted. The affected urban centers cannot be reached at this time by land; the roads are gone, the terrain is treacherously swamped out marshland. It is unknown if the residents had time to flee in large numbers, but the reporters and officials are assuming the worst.

Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/1759/cYTNZxgr/

Comments:
#12169: Stephen Brophy — 12/30  at  08:24 AM
Well said DS. our sentiments should be echoed throughout the developed world.



#12171: Stephen Brophy — 12/30  at  08:26 AM
err, that was meant to be 'Your sentiments'. Gosh, that little omission changes the whole character of that sentence :(



#12172: Andrew — 12/30  at  09:38 AM
Andy said "I guess it just aggravates me sometimes that no matter what happens, people will try to drag Bush into it." Yes, that is unfortunately true, but what's more unfortunate is that in this case he's really brought it on himself. He could so easily have put on a suit on the day, or even the day after, and made some kind of statement. It would have taken, what, a half hour of his time? And to get the press together I'm sure would have been no problem, what with him being the president and everything. I think that's what people are saying - that the impression is that he was totally indifferent and now has had to be shamed into reacting, which goes against all the rhetoric of the last couple of years: pre-emptive action, spreading peace and democracy, being partners with other nations etc.
And to note that like Isabel, I would have said the same thing about Kerry or anyone else who was the president and behaved in the same way (and I'll cheapen that sentence by saying that I can't imagine anyone else behaving the same way).



#12184: — 12/30  at  12:11 PM
DS, whaddya mean you don't want to bring politics into it?

You couldn't wait to drag Bush into it.

Your remarks about moderate Muslims are all wet, too.

I don't have any objection to your giving money (or time or prayers or whatever you think is valuable) to the survivors, but don't expect any gratitude for it.

You might ask yourself how much credit the Americans and Norwegians got from the moderate Muslims for their unpublicized and selfless efforts to eradicate guinea worm from the Koran Belt. They almost succeeded, too, except for a few places where they were unable to penetrate.

Answer: World Trade Center.



#12185: DarkSyde — 12/30  at  12:18 PM
I guess I'm not following Harry. You think that the crew that hit us on 9-11 were moderates? Or that there are no such thing as moderates? Or that somehow if we just ignore them and pay no attention to them, except when we're invading them, that this will somehow prevent another 9-11?



#12186: — 12/30  at  12:20 PM
Isabel, you don't need to apologize. My comment wasn't directed at anyone in particular. Rather, it was just me putting down my what ran through my head at the time. Although I didn't vote for Bush, I get weary with incessant Bush bashing. But if those who are more into politics want to go after him, and he deserves it, I'll just keep my weariness to myself and move on.



#12190: — 12/30  at  12:32 PM
Harry, Most (almost all!) of the WTC attackers were Saudis. Are you suggesting that this rich nation needed our help eradicating guinea worms? Are you suggesting our Saudi 'friends' made their country so it could not be penetrated by those trying to help from America and Norway?

Are you suggesting that the families of those drowned in SE Asia are Saudi's? al Quaeda members? Or are they, like Sadam, 'close enough' to justify US (and your) attack.

Tim McVey was a 'Christian', does that make all Christians suspect of being members of white hate groups who will blow up government buildings?



#12193: Hank Fox — 12/30  at  01:25 PM
Bush was recently on the news, making a statement from his ranch in Crawford, Texas. The news station played a single half-sentence from Bush, delivered in his "I am reading this off a sheet someone just handed me" voice, and then cut him off to continue with other footage and reporting. As if they knew that their audience knew what Bush was saying was calculated political puffery, and not very entertaining besides.

On the subject of people trying to bring Bush into everything, in this case Bush is bringing himself into it. And that makes him fair game for comment by every observer.



#12194: — 12/30  at  01:55 PM
I'm saying two things:

1. Yes, Muslims needed the help of westerners to eradicate guinea worm, which is, technically, simple, because they were too indifferent or brutal or something to do it for themselves.

2. If we were ever to get any credit from moderate Muslims, that was the event. No westerner got any benefits from eradicating guinea worm, which, if the violence of some Muslim countries had not prevented it, would have become the first instance in history of the eradication of a human parasite -- as significant, in the public health sense, as the eradication of smallpox. Heck, hardly any westerners had ever heard of guinea worm.

Guinea worm is at least as unpleasant and deadly as a tsunami, but while tsunami bother a few thousand Muslims once every 300 years, guinea worm afflicted 2 million Pakistanis/year every year, until the Americans/Norwegians took it in hand, not to mention additional tens of millions in Iran, India, North Africa -- whereever there was water, warmth, indifference and lousy sanitation.

What I'm saying is that there turned out to be no difference between the 'moderates' and the Saudis who actually flew the planes. How much love have the Pakistanis been giving you lately, DS?



#12196: DarkSyde — 12/30  at  02:20 PM
Yeah I know what they are, and you're right, they're hideous SOB's. The life cycle of a guinea worm isn't pretty. I'm just not getting how that relates to this. The Paks have given us far more cooperation than we ever would've had any right to expect. Probably more cooperation from Mushureef than all the other major Muslim nations put together. Considering the potential that Pakistan has, should they decide to throw in with the radicals, we're pretty damn lucky imo.

But this isn't about expecting something in return for me personally, this is about showing something upfront. I'm showing them, I'm not with those guys in DC. I'm not with Bush. He's not my guy.

If I don't get anyhing back, then no big deal.

As a nation thogh this is incomprehensible to me. It's not like we haven't blown, you know, a billion here and a billion there lately on some rather ill-conceived plans in the Muslim world.
It sure can't hurt our reputation to help. There is no risk it will damage our credibility. We'd just be out the money, and that money seems to come and go alot in that area lately with nothing to show for it all, except grisly horror anyway.
But if my government isn't going to take action, I can.

On another tact, honestly Harry, it wouldn't have been that big a deal for Bush to cut his godamn vacation two days short, fly to the area in luxury on his own private jumbo-jet, and look worried, if there was a chance it might do us some good in that community in the long run, now would it? I mean if he can order 100,000 men and women to leave their families for a year or two and play sandbags for insurgents on the off chance that it will do some long term good, is it really asking for too much on his part to have tried that?
I don't freakin think so. That's what makes me rather appalled. He didn't even try Harry. Yet he's claiming at every press conference he's doing everything in his power, burning the midnight oil boy howdy, to keep America safe! Except he's not willing to take a 24 hour luxury road trip, cuz, you know, he's busy and all. He's sending men and women off to their deaths in Iraq, on the off chance that it might all somehow work out, to keep America safe, and he can't take a chance on a godamn 24 hour plane trip because it's not worth it? He can't send somebody, like Cheney or Rice or what? A plane trip Harry. A hundred million bucks, BAM! On day one. No risk at all. A PR bonanza and plus it's the right thing to do both humanely, you know 'values wise' and because that region has been cooperating out the ying-yang, you know, trwat coooperation better than non cooperation. It's just stunning to me that not only are they cruel thoughtless bastards, they're not even good liars or PR hacks. he didn't come out of hiding until Clinton was on th air and some aids got kinda nervous. he got smoked out of his retreat 'clearing burch on the ranch' by Clinton. The guys is just not there man.



#12197: Kevin — 12/30  at  02:22 PM
Harry, what are you arguing? That because of 9/11 the west should not aid the people of southeast asia in this incredible disaster? Please say that isn't what you're saying.
Darksyde, thank you for your post. As far as Bush goes, I don't feel surprised, nor am I convinced that any of us or our leaders are doing enough- what could possibly be enough? My plan is to figure out what I can give and give it, and then try not to see too many of the pictures or read too many of the statistics. The scale of this is just too big, I honestly don't want to be confronted with it.



#12198: DarkSyde — 12/30  at  03:09 PM
Look, I bet we can have a contest right here in this comment section where everyday people can see the horrible opportunity we missed to not just help them, but to help ourselves...
Let's state why, if you were Bush, you would want to do this.

1. It's the right thing to do. It saves lives. This is a huge disaster and may end up being the single costliest natural event in human history
2. Those nations are moderates who have helped us a lot, we owe them and it would make a good example for everyone else.
3. It gets Iraq out of the headlines
4. It's zero risk PR
5. Bush likes looking important and heroic
6. We're talking 100 million and a plane trip. Rummy did a plane trip and we almost certainly spent over 100 million the day he went to Iraq to try and do some damage control for a single smart ass quip that got bad press.
7. BushCo didn't have anything else planned this week. He's on godamn vacation No one is sick, he's not having open heart surgery or anything
8. It fits in with BushCo's fancy claims that we're all about bringing stability to the Muslim world.
9. It allows us to send in military and NGO aid, which means we can place all kinds of agents and survelience in an extremely important part of the world in our WoT
10. There's going to be some serious building contracts in that area for the next few years
11. It makes BushCo look like they're serious about doing 'hard work' even if they're not, and this is a lay-up

That's all BushCo Prime Stuff ... Anything else?

So why the FUCK didn't they do anything? The only thing I can think of? They just didn't think, lterally. At all. They literally did not think of it. Because it's so obvious the advantages of doing something, that had they thought about it for 10 minutes, they would have been in there charging away.

WHAT THE HELL ARE THESE CLOWNS DOING IN CHARGE? This is stunning to me that these guys, who we are entrusting with our lives, whose whole shtick is "We go the extra mile to keep you safe and we're all about values", did not read this correctly until an Aid saw Bill Clinton giving an interview on Tuesday morning and thought "Hey, wait a minute...{wheels turning} maybe there's something going on here..."

I keep thinking I'm getting to the point where the incomptence can no longer surprise me, and then they always manage to prove me wrong.



#12199: covington — 12/30  at  03:53 PM
Simon Winchester argued convincingly in his book on Krakatoa that the eruption, and the subsequent Dutch colonial reaction to it, was one of the factors that led to the rise of militant islam.



#12200: DarkSyde — 12/30  at  04:07 PM
Yeah Cov. It's like a cross between that with the same methodology they showed on Kerik. They literally don't seem to think things through, at all. I mean it's weird man. Even some of the fundie bloggers are getting kinda of anxious waiting for the talking point ... and the WH knows they blew this at this point. They're painfully aware now of how bad they screwed up



#12201: — 12/30  at  04:24 PM
Well said, DarkSyde. I agree that turning this into fodder for "Bush bashing" would be inappropriate, and I think you dealt with that aspect of it quite well.

I don't think that the political facet of giving aid to this countries should be tip-toed around. If this is a democracy, we have the right, if not the responsibility, to make known to Bush and everyone else around him what we wish to do to help in this situation. They are our tax dollars, after all. When I first heard how much we pledged on the radio, I swear I thought they said "billion" not "million." I certainly agree that we could do much better than that. As you mentioned, I can't figure out why they didn't at least try to get some good PR out of it.

Jamie



#12202: Michael — 12/30  at  04:32 PM
My comment (#20) is now hopelessly out of date, as Britain alone has since increased its official contribution (i.e. not including charitable donations) to the equivalent of $95.7 million. The equivalent US contribution per capita would be approximately $480 million.



#12203: DarkSyde — 12/30  at  04:33 PM
I agree Jaime. It's rare that you get in this life a chance to do something which makes so much sense on so many levels and such low downside. Massive help right off the bat ... It makes moral, political, emotional, and both strategic and tactical military sense. It would be 100% popular by everyone in the country and the world. Nobody would even think about criticizing it. It is fantasticlly attractive at the local, regional, and international level, on a specific set of cultures already identified as critical to the safety and welfare of our future in the West. {shrug}. It's a no brainer. There is zero downside. You don't get too many situations like this handed to you. A situation where it's morally, politically, and militarily, completely, a no brainer. Those just don't come along everyday.

I think they know they missed their best shot already. And I think they could easily still save it. But this is where BushCo really pulls out the extra special freakiness and pretends they planned it this way the whole time. So they're not going to make much a fuss about it, because they'd be admitting they aren't perfect.
I'm giong to get off on a little bashing here in comments ... Man I'm telling you, I have never in my entire life experienced a WH that was this, fucking, geeked out about appearing perfect. You can almost see it when they go into this mode. All the sudden all information flow slows down, you don't see them on TV. I dunno know if they're off arguing somewhere, or they figure they'll just basically hide and hope something happens to take people's minds of it. I mean for all I know Bush could be off on a drinking/snorting binge or pulling some kind of latent nervous breakdown act, and everyone around him is flipped out of their gourds trying to cover for him when it happens. It almost has that kind of a freaky feel to it sometimes. The WH just freezes up.



#12208: DarkSyde — 12/30  at  08:23 PM
BTW: Death Count Now Could Reach The Half-million Mark. Appreantly some entire medium sized cities are lost. No survirors seen on ariel recon in three major towns on Indonesian shore, the populations add up to over 400k.



#12211: — 12/30  at  10:03 PM
Guess I will throw a little more gasoline on the fire. I am sure Shrub had access to recon on the damage and destruction long before we did. Satellite, recon planes and other sources were putting together the growing magnitude, hours before we got those rising figures.

When I first hear the $15 million number on the radio, I thought..."Say What?" This is the cost of building ONE moderate sized high school. You've got to be kidding.

So, even with the advantage of advance information Shrubco cant get ahead of almost everyone else on the planet on this issue. Blind, stupid, cheap, lazy, incompetent, devious, embarrasing, morons. Your Republican Party at work. Let us not forget, nobody else in the Republican Party is trying to step up to the plate either ... and they have a lame duck President to manuever for advantage against. What? Do they expect Cheney to take over the throne in 4 years? The sensible Republicans have abdicated so why dont they switch parties and throw the Senate to the Democrats .... of course that too would require a spine.



#12215: — 12/30  at  10:59 PM
Well, at least SE Asia will get a good view of our strange quasimonarchy in action. George is <a href="http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story2&u=/ap/20041231/ap_on_go_ca_st_pe/tsunami_us">sending Powell, but is making sure that Jeb is along as his handler. Wouldn't want Colin making nicely moderate statements, after all.

Rrawr!



#12216: — 12/30  at  11:00 PM
Oops. Forgot to close my tag. Sorry 'bout that.

Rrawr!



#12223: — 12/31  at  07:31 AM
Covington's right. And so is DarkSyde.

This tragedy presents a challenge to the west, and specifically to the U.S., to live up to our ideals. The failure to adequately deal with a similar tragedy may have sparked the fires of radical Islam -- is it possible that a great response today could quench that spark?

And even if the chance is only slight, is there any doubt that a lousy response would fan the fires?

Can we act as Good Samaritans to the world? How many sheckels? How big an inn? Those are the only serious questions we should be asking at the moment.



#12227: — 12/31  at  10:52 AM
Great post DS. Especially your followup where you list the reasons that doing more is even in Bush's cynical self interest, if nothing else. Truly mind boggling.

One question though, where are people getting all these 200,00-500,000 death toll numbers? I'm still seeing 124,000 dead on the BBC. Are these extrapolations taking into account starvation and disease in the coming weeks? Or are they still just referring to the immediate tsunami death toll?



#12228: — 12/31  at  10:54 AM
ack. I have no idea what I did to cause that. Sorry.



#12233: — 12/31  at  01:21 PM
Thanks for the response DS. Although given the answer, 'thank you' seems to not be quite the right sentiment.

Entire cities? Something about that sounds more horrifying than any number can.



Page 2 of 4 pages  <  1 2 3 4 >

Next entry: Housekeeping and Iraq

Previous entry: Open Thread: Evolution and IDC Discussions

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college