Pharyngula

Pharyngula has moved to http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/

Thursday, March 10, 2005

White lady

The animal I've been working with in my class lately is the beautiful beastie, Drosophila melanogaster. While I was cleaning out some stocks, I found this lovely example, a pale lady.

Drosophila white mutant

She is a white mutant, and so lacks the normal red pigment in her eyes. In addition, she had just recently eclosed from her pupal case, and although her wings looked neat and pressed, her cuticle hadn't yet fully tanned. She looked even more ghostly when I first spotted her, and was visibly darkening as I put her under the camera.

Here's a close-up. It's amazing how every hair has it's place, and she looks so neat and trim and glossy. Every hair has a nerve or nerves, and is a conduit for olfactory or tactile information, sending constant pulses of information down to her perfect tiny brain.

Drosophila white mutant

The white mutant is historically important. This was the first mutant isolated and studied by Thomas Hunt Morgan in 1910, and its discovery has been described in Jonathan Weiner's Time, Love, Memory (an excellent book, by the way, if you're at all interested in how science is done).

…after all those tens of thousands of more or less identical red-eyed flies, he found a single fly with white eyes.

Morgan's wife, Lilian, who was fascinated by his work and who later (after their children were out of the house and busy in school) made important contributions in the laboratory, was pregnant that year; and long afterward the birth of the new baby became mingled in the family history with the arrival of the mutant. Lilian loved to recall the scene when Morgan walked into her hospital room.

"Well, how is the white-eyed fly?" she asked. According to family lore, he was carrying the fly home at night to sleep in a jar next to their bed.

Morgan told her the fly looked feeble but it was hanging on. "And how is the baby?"

Within a week, one of their two new arrivals was old enough to breed (still another reason to work with flies). Morgan paired the white-eyed fly, which was male, with normal virgin female flies, and together they produced 1,237 young flies. The flies' children (as Morgan called them) had red eyes. The next week, Morgan arranged marriages for all of the children. He was fascinated to see that among the grandchildren, although all of the females had red eyes, about one in two of the males had white eyes. Naturally Morgan thought of Mendel's peas. When Mendel crossed short peas with tall peas, the first generation was all tall, and in the next generation three quarters of the plants were tall and one quarter was short. Shortness in Mendel's pea plants is what is now known as a recessive trait, like blue eyes among human beings. Morgan wondered if white eyes among male fruit flies could be a recessive trait too.

As one latter-day drosophilist likes to say now, "In the beginning there was white." The mutant fly white was the point of entry through which Morgan would establish the modern theory of the gene, the atomic theory of inheritance.

Drosophila white mutant

One of the strange things about doing science is that we can look at creatures like this and admire their beauty and appreciate their significance, but of course we also have to be pragmatic. All these pretty little jewels ended up in my fish tanks, where the Danios greatly appreciated their flavor.


Trackback url: http://pharyngula.org/index/trackback/2010/B1uSa178/

Comments:
#18267: Wayne — 03/10  at  06:16 PM
Very nice! The Lady in White. Was Morgan's first mutants male or female? I'd suppose male.



#18268: RPM — 03/10  at  06:26 PM
I'm surprised you didn't mention Morgan's initial disdain for Mendelian genetics. He was trained as a developmental biologist (insert joke here) and wasn't too keen on Mendel's theory. It is quite ironic that Morgan played such a large role in shaping modern genetics considering his opinions prior to domesticating Drosophila. Check out Lords of the Fly for more great insights on Drosophila genetics.

You should've flipped her over and shown off her lovely meconium. As an undergrad, I would be terrible about clearing flies and collecting virgins, so I often just would come into the lab once a day and collect virgins based on their meconiums. It was inefficient, but I was extremely undedicated.



#18275: Michael — 03/10  at  09:01 PM
Hey, feeding them to your fish is better than dropping them into used motor oil, which is how we got rid of them after counting when I was in college, back in the Dark Ages.



#18294: JD — 03/10  at  11:56 PM
This brings back horrible memories of hundreds of these knocked out with ether under the macroscope, counting the red-eyes, black-eyes, whites and wild-types. Still, nice to look at all close up like.



#18295: Hungry Hyaena — 03/11  at  12:04 AM
Fantastic images and contagious enthusiasm. Thank you.



#18303: CKL — 03/11  at  04:26 AM
PZ,

I never knew you were an aquarist. What species do you keep?



#18308: Sissy Willis — 03/11  at  04:51 AM
Catbloggers be warned. The flybloggers are coming, The flybloggers are coming.



#18310: Mrs Tilton — 03/11  at  05:15 AM
Wow; just Wow!

Any chance of some online lessons in photomicrography (or would it be 'microphotography', or even perversely, given the relative bigness of Drosophila compared with cells an' stuff, 'macrophotography'?) I'm guessing you've mounted a digital camera to a trinocular dissecting scope - that's the rig I hope someday to own meself, if the Science Fairy ever puts such a thing, or its price in cash, under my pillow. I might then be able to get some half-decent arachnosnaps.



#18320: — 03/11  at  07:15 AM
D'you want some more Danios? I'll run them down to the Emerald City, if you want. They're freakin' out my kribs with their hyper behaviour!



Trackback: Friday Ark Tracked on: Modulator (63.247.135.223) at 2005 03 11 02:12:04
Cats, Dogs, Spiders and ? every Friday. I'll post links to sites that have Friday (plus or minus a few days) photos of their chosen animals as I see them (photoshops at my discretion and humans only in supporting roles). Leave a comment or trackback to this post or email me and I'll add yours to the list. Check back...



Trackback: There's a mouse in the house Tracked on: sisu (66.151.149.25) at 2005 03 11 05:00:42
There are mice under the sink, and Tiny's just the one to flush them out. We spotted one in the garbage can (upper right) just the other day.Going out to the kitchen after supper, we came upon a mousing



#18323: — 03/11  at  07:57 AM
Well, this was a refreshing bit of a cheer up for me after the fairly depressing encounter I had yesterday...ran into a third year biology major from Loyola University who's never heard of either Ernst Mayr or the modern synthesis. All I could think was "What are they teaching this girl"? Oh, yeah - I also thought "Rarely is the question asked: is our children learning?", but that just left me even more depressed.

Thanks for the reminder that people still get involved in biology because they actually think it's neato, not because it leads to a lucrative career.



's avatar #18324: PZ Myers — 03/11  at  08:06 AM
No, thanks, bish -- my Danios are all from defined genetic lines, so we don't let any ol' riff-raff in.

Mrs Tilton: I took those with a Wild M3C and a Nikon Coolpix, so you're exactly right. The Nikons come with a threaded lens so it's trivial to attach an adapter and slip it onto the trinoc. There's a Yahoo group with lots of information on this stuff.

You can get a decent dissecting scope fairly cheaply nowadays -- at least, it's no more expensive than getting a computer. I'm partial to Wild/Leica and Zeiss, which are on the high end, but I know Olympus makes some good scopes, too.

I can also use the same camera on my research scope (not affordable for home use, unfortunately, unless you're willing to shell out the same amount you would for a mid-range car).

I do have some step-by-step write-ups on taking pictures with this rig that I put together for my students. It would be easy enough to dump them here, I suppose.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#18329: Jude — 03/11  at  08:39 AM
What lovely creatures they are.



#18352: — 03/11  at  10:49 AM
I am very fond of this particular bit of scientific history, as this was (I believe) the first concrete piece of evidence linking genes to chromosomes -- the white gene turns out to be on the X chromosome, and so the trait can be followed through generations being inherited in the same pattern as that one particular chromosome.



#18380: — 03/11  at  03:25 PM
Oh, goodness, I thought Creationist Crackpot was joking, so I clicked on his link. Eww! I have to go take a bath now.... Can you wash off stupidity?



#18383: RPM — 03/11  at  03:46 PM
PZ is a filthy liar. Everyone knows evolution is not an experimental science.

I better go tell my advisor this before he lets me do any more experiments.



's avatar #18387: PZ Myers — 03/11  at  04:12 PM
I don't know if he was joking or not, but that link, to the vile Rev. Phelps, is far beyond the bounds of good taste. That comment is getting taken out.

PZ Myers
Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota, Morris



#18415: — 03/11  at  10:45 PM
Woot! I'm taking a break from writing my thesis on Drosophila eye development.

I would recommend the little article in the 2000 Science issue with the publication of the melanogaster genome (by Rubin, a scientific mentor-mentor of mine, and Ed Lewis who is one of the Nobel winners) on the history of the fly in genome research. The discoveries are pretty amazing: Sturtevant with the first genetic map and linear gene order in 1913, Bridges showing chromosomes contain genes in 1914, Muller using X-Rays to introduce chromosomal aberrations in 1927 and then physical mapping genes using polytene chromsomes by Painter in 1934. The first random clone insert library was generated by Hogness in 1974, and that represents the start of modern genome research, and Lewis used these to positionally clone the first genes, the Bithorax cluster, in 1979. The list of course goes on: saturation mutagenesis, efficient transgenesis, shotgun sequencing and assembly, full genome annotation, etc.

It's certainly made my last 5 years easier...



#18423: dr. charles — 03/12  at  12:50 AM
very nice... i can still remember my own drosophila breeding experiments from biology class, and the amazing confirmation of mendelian genetics that my particular crosses yeilded.



Page 1 of 1 pages

Next entry: Flooding the ark

Previous entry: That revolting article about earwax and smegma

<< Back to main

Info

email PZ Myers
Search
Archives
UMM—America's best public liberal arts college